Thanks Alex.

I did searches on every combination of expand/collapse, accordion, tree,
etc I could think of on flexcoders and did come across a few interesting
ideas. Most notably is a list of custom itemRenderers that
expand/collapse based on a open/close property set in the data override.

http://tech.groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/59924
<http://tech.groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/59924>

Unfortunately I didn't find anything that looked like what I need.

I've gone back and looked at the accordion container several times and
it's definitely closer in some ways to what I need. However, if you look
at the following example you can see some of the issues I still have.

http://www.useflashmore.com/flex-as3-scrollable-accordion-menu/accordion\
-component-test/ScrollableAccordionTest.html
<http://www.useflashmore.com/flex-as3-scrollable-accordion-menu/accordio\
n-component-test/ScrollableAccordionTest.html>

and the source:

http://www.useflashmore.com/flex-as3-scrollable-accordion-menu/accordion\
-component-test/srcview/index.html
<http://www.useflashmore.com/flex-as3-scrollable-accordion-menu/accordio\
n-component-test/srcview/index.html>

Major Requirements (likely requiring core overrides implementing custom
logic)
----------------------------

1. All containers should be collapsed when the control is first opened,
or at least the first time the control is shown.
2. Cascading tweens in the use case when the parent node's sibling is
clicked, the current open branch should tween closed first, then the
clicked node branch should open  (see the AS2 example when clicking on
any parent node when a child node is already open)
3. Container resizing. As child branches, expand/collapse, the root
container should resize at the same time as the branches resize (similar
to a tree). The Accordion control cascades the resize, it doesn't happen
in parallel as I need.
4. Recursive levels. A Branch with with 3 or more levels of nodes
presents a variety of resize tween issues that seems difficult to
overcome with the accordion container

Minor Annoyances (probably could be easily fixed with an few more hours
of tweaking)
--------------------------
1. What the heck, and more importantly, where the heck is the style
setting for the padding/space on an accordion menu header that doesn't
have  any children?
2. Child containers are not sized to the content
3. drop shadow on the parent siblings to act as a visual cue of which
branch is currently active. (see the AS2 example when the sub menu is
opened)

At this point I'm thinking it probably makes sense to just rebuild the
component by extending the ScrollControlBase class or UIComponent. It
just seems that massaging any of the above components to look/behave the
way I want would likely take as long if not longer than developing
something from scratch or rather from my AS2 version. If I'm on crazy
pills, please let me know.

In case anyone is interested, I'm blogging my process.

http://www.useflashmore.com <http://www.useflashmore.com>

Reply via email to