A roofing filter is "tuned" to a particular frequency of the IF stage it is employed at. A preselector is a variable frequency and Q filter at the antenna input. A filter is a filter is a filter. :-)
-Tim -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Frank Karnauskas N1UW Sent: Friday, July 31, 2009 12:28 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Flexradio] Roofing filter So, to prove that I am a better devil's advocate than I am technically competent: How (functionally) is the preselector different than a roofing filter? I understand that they work differently, but in the end wouldn't either accomplish the same thing? Frank N1UW This is the first time I have been learning something new since God created surface mounted components. -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 31, 2009 9:59 AM To: [email protected] Cc: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Flexradio] Roofing filter --- [email protected] wrote: From: "Frank Karnauskas N1UW" <[email protected]> To: <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [Flexradio] Roofing filter Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2009 09:22:11 -0500 Frank, Answers below in line, Two Questions: 1) Wouldn't the panadapter would look pretty quiet outside the preselector bandpass? Yes, the Panadapter is just about totally clean, you don't see any other signals on the screen outside of what the preselectors bandwidth, as in my fist email. 2) Isn't this re-engineering a 5000 to work like a conventional radio? Wiser to invest the effort on better software than more of the components we are trying to get away from? Not really, a preselector is normally an external device that is placed in the RF path outside of the radio, it has no impact on how the signal is processed within the radio. The preselector normally has the input connectred directly to the antanna and the output to the antenna input of the receiver. An expample is if you were operating at 14.200 center frequency, 14.197 - 14.203 would pass through the preselector with little attenuation, all other rf within the band would be attenuated by the filters within the preselector. This bandwidth is adjustable on some preselectors, like on the Harris unit that I use, I can tighten it up to 3 Khz. If a preselctor was designed for the flex, the best way would be to have it would be to have the Flex control the tuned frequency of the preselector and key line functions from receive to transmit mode, but not be a part of the Flex. Cheers, Frank N1UW Remember there are no stupid questions, only stupid people asking them...and that would be me! :-) -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of [email protected] Sent: Friday, July 31, 2009 8:52 AM To: [email protected] Cc: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Flexradio] Roofing filter I really don't think that a traditional "roofing filter" would help out the FLEX 5000's, but what might be an interesting idea would be a very tight "RF Preselector" like we use to use in the fixed military HF sites around the world. The preselector is basically a very tight HF Filter at the actual operating frequency. Collins used these with their HF 80 series receivers. I currently use a Harris surplus military preselector in my receive loop and it makes a world of difference on my Flex 5000A. I've got it set up to allow 3Khz up and down from my actual center frequency and everything else is 40db down. A preselector won't help in removing close noise, like 1 or 2kc's away, but it does get rid off all of the funky things on the screen from extremely strong stations and stations outside of the 6Khz bandwidth that are putting out dirty signals and splattering all over the place or if your operating multiple stations from the same location on the same band. The only problem with using a Harris preselector, is it does not follow the operating frequency automatically, so if you change frequencies, you must also manually tune the preselector. The other issue that I see with a preselector the way I have it installed in the Receive loop, where you would normally put a pre-amp, is I don't see any signals on the screen outside of my 6 Khz, but I normally just park it on a frequency and work DX and don't run up and down the band much, when I'm operating. But for a newly designed preselector it would be possible for the receive RF to be displayed on the screen, while the rf was routed to the preselector. In the past preselectors where big, bulky and expensive. I paid over $600.00 for my surplus Harris, but it was totally clean and operational, but I do run 2 to 3 operating positions sometimes, so it was well worth it. 73's, Mike KE7WRJ --- [email protected] wrote: From: <[email protected]> To: "Joe Roth-WC4R" <[email protected]>, "flexradio" <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [Flexradio] Roofing filter Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2009 14:52:49 +0200 Hello Joe, my 2 (Euro) cents What is (the function of) a roofing filter, see next 2 links: - http://www.qth.com/inrad/roofing-filters.pdf "A few words about intermodulation dynamic range and roofing filters" - http://wapedia.mobi/en/Roofing_filter "A roofing filter is a type of filter used in a HF <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/High_frequency> receiver ( shortwave <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/Shortwave> radio <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/Radio> ). It is usually found after the first receiver mixer. The goal of a roofing filter is to reduce the passband <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/Passband> of the 1st intermediate frequency (IF) to about 6-20 kHz <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/Hertz> , so that overloading and distortions by the following amplifier <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/en/Amplifier> stages and mixers are reduced" In the FLEX tranceivers the 1st receiver mixer is followed by an A/D converter (with anti-aliasing filter). The only passband filtering following this is in software and determines the passband with "brick-wall filtering". This filter is the roofing filter and final filter in one. It is a VARIABLE (both in a bit in center frequency and bandwith) "roofing filter" it does not need additional hardware. Care must be taken not to overload the 1stmixer + A/D converter. No problem in the FLEX frontends with their hi dynamic range 73s Peter pa0pvn groeten Peter website http://www.homepages.hetnet.nl/~petervn/ <https://netmail.hetnet.nl/exchweb/bin/redir.asp?URL=http://www.homepages.he tnet.nl/~petervn/> petervn-at-hetnet-nl pa0pvn-at-hetnet-nl pa0pvn-at-amsat-org only large files: pa0pvn-at-gmail-com There are 10 kind of people, those who can count to 1010 on their fingers, and those who count to 1111111111. ________________________________ Van: [email protected] namens Joe Roth-WC4R Verzonden: vr 31-7-2009 2:53 Aan: 'flexradio' Onderwerp: [Flexradio] Roofing filter I read why the Flex 5000 does not use a roofing filter somewhere. As I recall it was due to the RX design. I can't find that info now and I would like to find out exactly why roofing filters do not have a place in the 5000/3000. Thanks, Joe www.rothweb.net www.WilliamsburgWX.com www.wc4r.com _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected] _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected] _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected] _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected] _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected] _______________________________________________ FlexRadio Systems Mailing List [email protected] http://mail.flex-radio.biz/mailman/listinfo/flexradio_flex-radio.biz Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexradio%40flex-radio.biz/ Knowledge Base: http://kc.flex-radio.com/ Homepage: http://www.flex-radio.com/ Message delivered to [email protected]

