Trying to get listed by the FSF is an exercise in futility.

The FSF has long ago ceased being about technology.  It's a religion,
and Richard Stallman is its prophet.  (I've met him, and know people
who've known him for decades. He's an odd person. In Stallman's world,
all software is FOSS, issued under the GPL.  No surprise various Linux
distros don't pass his compatibility tests.)

And open source has fragmented.  My irony meter pegs off scale when
one open source product cannot incorporate code from another because
they are issued under incompatible licenses. (And Gnu is a Worst
Offender - my understanding is that GPLv3 is incompatible with GPLv2.
That's just hopelessly stupid.)

FreeDOS began as an effort to produce an  open source OS compatible
with DOS.  It mostly succeeded.

But people buy computers to do work or play, and the OS sits between
the user,. the program they run, and the hardware.  A *lot* of
programs people want to run *aren't* open source, and won't be.
Consider the popular DOSBox DOS emulator.  *It* began as an effort to
create an emulator that would let people play old DOS games on things
that weren't DOS PCs.  Those games were not open source, nor likely to
become so. And folks here want to run DOS character mode emulation for
productivity applications like word processors and spreadsheets.
Those are highly unlikely to be open source, and even if open source
products exist, people will want to run what they used back when.  If
what you ran is Lotus 123,  there may not be a shareware or open
source product that *can* replace it because they will lack Lotus 123
features you relied on.

Even if it were possible for FreeDOS to get listed by the FSF, what
would FreeDOS get out of it that would make the hoops worth trying to
jump through?

Ignore the FSF.  The rest of the world increasingly is.  Developments
I'm following these days are generally under MIT or 2 clause BSD
licenses, precisely to make the license as open and unrestricted as
possible, and allow code sharing to happen.
______
Dennis


_______________________________________________
Freedos-user mailing list
Freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-user

Reply via email to