On 20/11/12 17:50, Panagiotis Georgopoulos wrote:

       91 0d
      501 03
     4848 15
     7540 01
    35801 19

So, about 75% PEAP, 10% TTLS, 15% identity packets, less than 0.2% TLS.

Thanks a lot for this specific results. Essentially you are proving my point :-)

At first you said that 99.9% is PEAP and practise says that 75% is PEAP (even 
in just 4
hours). Essentially this is what I am after, to see whether what I am reading 
online is
also what happens in practice (in terms of deployment and usage) (and then 
search why).

Sorry, but you're misunderstanding the stats, or reading too much into them.

These are EAP types from EAP *packets*, not sessions. And, as I said, it excludes our *own* users (i.e. it's just visitors) which removed several hundred thousand PEAP packets from the count.

EAP-Identity doesn't count as an auth type; there is one EAP packet for every session, at the start.

If you exclude the Identity packets (type 1) and NAK packets (type 3) you have:


       91 0d
     4848 15
    35801 19

This is 87% PEAP. However, this is still *packets*. It takes no account of sessions, of the client re-auth times, TLS session resumption, and so forth, and is still just for visitors.

I'm afraid I don't have time to do more detailed processing. But really, you would want to "unique" any stats by client (Calling-Station-Id) and EAP-type, and measure "EAP type client days" or something.
-
List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html

Reply via email to