|
Thanks, Ray. I guess I generally agree with the
point you're making. However, my point remains that there are many
communities in Canada's middle north that seem to have fallen into a kind of
permanent trauma and that resist almost anything that can be done from within or
without to get them moving again. Ever so many things are tried by
energetic locals and by groups such as Bear Woman Associates, but in the end
there's little forward motion. The one constant seems to be the commensal
relation between the locals and the bureaucracy. The locals forage in the
bureaucracy and the bureaucrats need the locals to justify their jobs and
paychecks.
I'm referring mostly to communities that are part of
now ancient arrangements like the Numbered Treaties, not communities that are
part of the modern claims process. In the latter case, because rights to
land and self-government have been constitutionally established, there is
considerable hope and forward motion. From all I've heard and read, the
Cree of northern Quebec are doing a very good job of running their own schools
(in their own language), their health services, etc. The Inuvialuit of the
Mackenzie Delta, the Nisga'a of the BC coast, and several of the Dene groups in
the Mackenzie Valley and Yukon also seem to have a pretty good handle on
things. I don't know how much impact this has had on various community
pathologies (alcohol, suicide, etc.), but I would bet that it has been
positive.
Yet for communities that are part of older
arrangements, like the Numbered and earlier treaties, the patterns are long
established and almost, it would seem, carved in stone. The bureaucrats
administer and the locals comply. Many of the locals have a vested
interest in compliance. Those who don't want to comply move off the
reservation, most often into the urban slums of Winnipeg or Edmonton.
Except for arguments that they may not have gotten everything they were supposed
to under their treaty, such communities don't have much of a case in
court. And they are too small and scattered to pose much of a threat to
anyone. So, on and on it goes.
Ed
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, January 05, 2004 1:14
AM
Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for
Manhattan (shortened)
Actually Ed, I agree with Keith on
this. Anthropologist Rayna Green the Cherokee anthropologist
and administrator at the Smithsonian, did a study of the farm culture in rural
Vermont and New Hampshire and found the same symptoms that you describe for
your communities. Her point was pretty much the same as
Keiths. Like the college inmates in the prison study that he
pointed out, it doesn't really matter where you are from, if you get put
into a situation of environmental stress, and hopelessness the answers are
pretty universal. The problem in those communities are not from
within but from without. Rupert Ross has written extensively about
the legal issues in those communities and the Iroquois communities in Canada
have, through a resurgence of the religion and education been experiencing a
mighty renaissance in Eastern Canada. I went to an Iroquois
Condolence Ceremonial tonight and the Mohawk folks who had accepted the
European path were all literally blown away with the depth and richness of
what they had lost through the oppression. They signed on to
the Renaissance. The same is happening with the Sun Dance cultures
and even our secret culture is springing to life in the children.
The point is whether we can teach them or not. Whether too much
has been lost for them to have a whole life. That is the challenge
for traditional peoples everywhere.
Generally I agree with what you have written and I
certainly don't mean to demean your experience and considerable
insight. I'm just saying that it is good to look in the other
direction such as my well worn comments about both you and Keith calling
forester cultures "Hunter Gatherer" when that is a political term from a
European American Racist Lewis Cass which has been taken on by Archeologists
to describe tribes in the pleistocene. These people are much more
sophisticated than that and their educational techniques have evolved along
with the rest of the world and the religions are more accepting of current
science than the European religions. So foresters and gardeners
they are while some groups have lost control of their land and forgotten
things once the forest went to seed. Another possibility is that
they have accepted Harry's second assumption and now just do what they can to
get by. But I don't think so. We could say that
heresy in any culture is a universal problem.
REH
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, January 04, 2004 7:01
PM
Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for
Manhattan (shortened)
Sorry Keith, I don't think we're talking about the same kind of thing.
You are talking about communities in transition, that need to make
adjustments to change and make them in a variety of ways, some healthy,
others not. I'm talking about communities that have been left behind in the
process of change, communities where a lot of things have happened but
nothing further really does - stuck communities where people are losers, but
that's OK because it's not your fault. Someone else has done that to you -
government I guess, or whatever. I describe my impressions of some
communities in northern Saskatchewan on my website at : http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/north_saskatchewan.htm .
Do take a look. I haven't looked at it for a couple of years but, to my
surprise on revisiting it, I still think it says something.
Ed
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, January 04, 2004 10:10
AM
Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads
for Manhattan (shortened)
Ed,
I venture to chip in
here:
At 08:40 04/01/2004 -0500, you wrote:
Thanks for clarifying, Natalia. I don't think I can add
much to what's already been said except that all people share a common
humanity that consists of a variety of elements, good and bad. How
these emerge and are excercised depends greatly on their circumstances,
and only the people who live with those circumstances have a real
understanding of them. One would expect that the more isolated our
Aboriginal communities are, the less they are influenced by mainstream
culture, the healthier they should be. As one learns from the
boreal and Artic communities of Canada, it ain't necessarily so.
In many of the communities, the young sniff gas or commit suicide, while
parents won't stop drinking until they are dead. Is this the
impact of mainstream society, or is it something else, perhaps endemic
to the culture? I would suggest that there's
nothing endemic here. Basically, the individuals in these indigenous
communities (that is, those that are fast becoming ex-communities) are
intrinsically as psychologically healthy as anybody else. But I'm
increasingly convinced that culture shock is vastly under-rated. All this
alcoholism and so forth seems to be repeated everywhere in the world when
cultural adjustments are needed or expected or enforced. Adjusting to a
totally new culture is a multi-generational, historical matter and
achieved only with difficulty. This is the big problem with the Middle
East countries, too -- except it's not alcoholism in their case but
aggression against the west. (They'd like to incorporate some of the
products of the west, but only selectively, and don't realise
[understandably] that our products are embedded within a totally different
culture.) In truth, modern civilisation is disembowelling their
communities without offering anything that's obvious or satisfying in
return -- only artificial substitutes (consumer goods).
As a study I did on community and social health in
northern Saskatchewan some ten years ago revealed, we simply don't
know. It goes on, seemingly beyond our ability to understand
it. M'mm ..... I think it *is* understandable, as
I've tried to indicate above. I think there *is* a new sense of community
building up in the developed countries but it is a subtle one among the
middle-class and intellgentsia, and not based on locality but on the
telephone. It is called "networking" these days. (A brand new urban-type
community to replace the previous countryside communities was building up
fast in the 1860-1930 period in England -- the co-operative movement, the
building societies, the trade unions (the flavour of which I managed to
experience myself in teenagerhood in some of the "slum" districts of
Coventry) -- but this, in turn, has been quickly overwhelmed with the
onward march of technology. There are *no* "ordinary" communities (that
is, of mixed abilities) anywhere in England now. (The only one possible
communities I can think of these days are the football and rugger crowds
that meet once a week at a match. Even the pubs are losing their community
basis as they become restaurants for the middle class.) I think that the
need for local community is very powerful and it will return, but *how* it
will do so intrigues and worries me, and whether it will take place
only among the middle-class/intelligentsia (because only they will have
dependable jobs and homes they can maintain adequately in the coming
years) worries me even more.
Keith Hudson
Regards, Ed
----- Original Message -----
- From: Darryl and
Natalia
- To: Ed Weick ; Ray Evans Harrell ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Saturday, January 03, 2004 10:39 PM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
(shortened)
- Hi Ed, More below in italics.
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Ed Weick
- To: Darryl and
Natalia ; Ray Evans Harrell
; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Saturday, January 03, 2004 11:22 AM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Natalia, a few comments
below.
- Ed
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Darryl and
Natalia
- To: Ed Weick ; Ray Evans Harrell ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Friday, January 02, 2004 5:52 PM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Thank You Ed and Ray,
- Ed, I appreciate what you have written and understand that you
have more in-depth knowledge of Native Peoples' histories than most.
Your posts are indeed sensitively presented, as Ray said.
- Let me mention a couple of things. You said we paint Native people
as simple, peaceful and trusting. I would not use the word simple
unless it were to denote truthful, and by that I give credit to living
according to needs of a full rich life that harms no one and ensures
well being within both community and environment. Simplicity is the
prerequisite for all invention and usually the answer to our most
complicated problems, materially, intellectually and spiritually. Our
complication of the hierarchy of needs has so fractured Western
society that we can't even admit that we need to clean up pollution in
our air and water. We fear more what we'll do without our pollution
and wars than the price we pay to have them. Short term gain
disinherits the children, and reverses almost every bit of progress we
have made, but our priority of needs continues to cloud our minds to
the fact that we are seriously dishonouring our home planet, and the
life upon it including ourselves. Even our intellectual solutions, I'd
suggest, are competing for complexity, and come with a hefty price.
Most often as well, these solutions are giving into the reality of
complication as a necessary thing, thereby overlooking the obvious as
the solution.
- Unfortunately, today's Native people, because of modern society,
cannot afford not to deal with the complexities that have been
thrust upon them. I think, however, that their belief in what is
obviously a healthy and well spirited approach to life will win out in
the long run, as it will for all of us.
- I don't know about this. Native
people, even before contact with whites, led lives every bit as
complex as Europeans or indeed any other people. They had to
battle with hunger, cold and disease and very often with each
other. They had to govern themselves and placate whatever Gods
or spirits they had to deal with. To raise them up on some kind
of pedestal is, IMHO, to deny them their basic humanity.
- *** Before contact with whites, Native people did not deal with
forty-fifty different government departments just to live in
accordance with law. Displacement, suppression of
spirituality/religion, families torn apart, forced sterilization,
abuses and injustices of all sorts, having to abandon a way of life
and adopt new survival methods within the asphyxiating pressures of
racism. These were additional complications which I do not suggest
they can't deal with. I believe you are misinterpreting what I am
saying about the rewards of a life without Western complications.
Their life was as complicated as a life need be. This is not to say
that their lives were not complex. It is that their focus was more
aligned with good values, in my opinion. This is not deification.
There are other people round the globe who (have) lived as peacefully
or even more so. But this is their land, and in my estimate, their
basic beliefs, had they been followed by the colonizers, would have
resulted in a healthier environment with fewer injustices. I do not
believe in deification of my fellow humans. We are equal in every
sense that is true, and when we forget that it is true, we are crying
out for help.
- I am aware that not all Native people lived peacefully, nor do
they today. I made a generalization, which was not intended to deify,
but drawn as a comparative. Their way of life was generally more
respectful of others and the life around them, otherwise towards the
end of Native peoples' fifty to one hundred thousand years of
responsible dominion of the lands the colonizers would have found a
toxic wasteland. This has nothing to do with lack of ingenuity,
sophistication or even luck. It was the result of living a life more
in keeping with the laws of Creation. I call the colonizers mean and
ignorant because they were both. They did intend genocide, and they
were ignorant, just as most people (governments) are today, because
they would destroy or exploit whatever came their way, making their
own needs, so-devised, as pre-eminent.
- I'm not sure of what you mean by "the laws of Creation". If there are
such things, are you suggesting that some people have special access
to them and others do not? And, as far as Native tenure over the
lands of the Americas goes, anything I've read suggests that it does
not extend back more than 20k years and 30k years at the very
most. For a very readable book on the topic, take a look at
Elaine Dewar, "Bones - Discovering the First Americans". And, as
for the colonizers, they were indeed mean though not, as I argued
previously, necessarily ignorant. And, for the most part, they
may not even have that mean. Ever so many people came to Canada
to escape the tyranny, poverty and oppressions of Europe and to take
up land that they genuinely believed were empty and therefore
available for farming. My grandfather, a God fearing man without
a mean bone in his body, was one of them. My point is that
people in high places may have known those lands were not empty, but I
don't think the ordinary pioneer farmer gave it much thought. He
just wanted to look after the survival of his family.
- As above, I do not belief specialness leads to anything but our
undoing. Yes, I heard about the thirty year tenure, and thought I'd
hypothesize a bit for the sake of accuracy when posterity reads this.
Keith's posts got me wondering, but I think there's still a lot to
uncover about human history all over the globe. We disagree about
"ignorant", yet I would say it of the Canadian government isolating
the Japanese immigrants in special camps, of not just German
government,for enslavement/genocide of the Slavic, Jewish, Gypsy, etc.
people during WWII, and of the U.S. government for today's overseas
oil wars. The ordinary citizen of any of these countries is not
necessarily responsible for poor government, but colonizers knew
pretty quickly that they were deposing Native people of their lands.
They didn't usually try to be fair about forced sharing/turfing.
Native people were more willing to share, given their belief that no
one owns what "Creator" has provided as a gift. Also, the notion that
colonizers came to escape tyranny was usually negated by burning
uppity women as witches, intolerance of Native peoples' religion, and
slavery of blacks--to mention but a few.
- "Laws of Creation" as in the Creator's Laws--nothing to do with
Creationist theory. I thought that consistent with Christian
understanding, but perhaps I could say God's Laws -- also up for
interpretation by humans.
- Trust was used by me in every sense that Christian philosophy
would imply. The alleged message of Jesus was to always trust in your
brother/sister. Where would we be, for example, without genuine
forgiveness? This is not the same as saying trust blindly or simply to
obey the laws of religion. If one chooses to trust another knowing
that great harm will come then you honour neither party. Trust that
deep down everyone wants peace, trust that we all come from the same
Source, and that we would do harm to our own selves, or dishonour the
Creator's trust, when we harm others--that is the trust of which I
speak.
- I think Native people learned not to
trust us very early on, whether by "trust" you mean something legal or
something more fundamental. Quite rightly, they never did trust
us and still don't, which is why all those treaties, agreements,
pieces of legislation and government departments dealing with
White/Native relationships. A few years ago, Angela Slaughter, a
Micmac, and I put together a primer on the treaties and claims process
in Canada and you might take a look at it at:
- http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/native_claims.htm
- I meant it in the fundamental sense, and I didn't think that my
Christian example could be otherwise interpreted. Yes, they did trust
white man in the beginning. Today, that trust is still extended to
individuals, though rightly not to government.
- I'll check out the above site, and thanks for the road trip
account.
- Natalia
- Regards, Ed
- ----- Original Message -----
- From: Ed Weick
- To: Ray Evans Harrell ;
Darryl and Natalia ; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Sent: Friday, January 02, 2004 9:53 AM
- Subject: Re: [Futurework] Fw: Beads for Manhattan
- Thanks, Ray. I'll file your
posting for future reference. Incidentally, I visited the site
of the Wounded Knee massacre in 1983. If you want my
impressions, go to http://members.eisa.com/~ec086636/black_hills.htm
.
- Ed
_______________________________________________ Futurework
mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://fes.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework
Keith
Hudson, Bath, England, <www.evolutionary-economics.org>
|