Hey Bill- this is just the feedback we need. I'm embarrassed to admit that I had them bookmarked and hadn't noticed that they were still in "New". I agree with you that "New" is where they should be, but- as you well know- this is a large initiative that Ralph could use some help with even before presenting class skeletons. That said, I also mentioned that we *really* need use cases in my comments; Ralph, it's clear that's our top priority here. I would like to stress that both Ralph and I feel that we need continuous community feedback during the process of bring these proposals to a first draft state. Ralph has taken on a monumental task; it's somewhat analogous to creating our entire MVC implementation in one go. I guess I should have made it clearer that these proposals are exceptional in that regard; please do *not* wait to give your feedback until they've been fully polished up. Ralph needs all the feedback he can get right now.
Thanks. ,Wil > -----Original Message----- > From: Bill Karwin [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Wednesday, July 02, 2008 4:49 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [fw-general] Why haven't you reviewed the Zend_Tool > proposals? > > > > wllm wrote: > > > > Why haven't you reviewed the Zend_Tool proposals? > > > > Well, the first thing I notice is that the proposals aren't filed under > "Ready for Review!" > > They're filed under "New", which is honestly where they should be at > this > stage, because the proposals are far from complete. > > Zend_Tool_CodeGenerator: > - nothing written under Requirements and Acceptance Criteria (only that > it > should use Zend_Reflection, which is an implementation detail, not a > requirement) > - nothing written under Use Cases > - nothing written under Class Skeletons > > Zend_Tool_Project: > - only two lines under Requirements and Acceptance Criteria > - only one Use Case written > - nothing written under Class Skeletons > > Zend_Tool_Rpc: > - only four lines under Requirements and Acceptance Criteria (two of > which > are "will not" exclusions) > - nothing written under Use Cases > - nothing written under Class Skeletons > > Regards, > Bill Karwin > -- > View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Why-haven%27t-you- > reviewed-the-Zend_Tool-proposals--tp18221384p18249243.html > Sent from the Zend Framework mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
