I'm afraid I have to report that this did not work for me.  I have spent
several days trying to get multicast traffic to route between two interfaces
and have had no success.

I have exactly the configuration you outline below--

I was unable to get A to see any ganglia traffic from b[1..n] or c[1..n].
A could only see B and C data if the gmond on those machines used the
interface connecting to A.  If B and C used the interfaces connecting to
b[1..n] and c[1..n], then B could only see itself and b[1..n]. C could
only see itself and c[1..n].  B and C never saw A in this mode either.

I am running kernel 2.4.9 with multicast routing enabled in the kernel
and did the echo thing shown below but got no joy.

Chris

On Friday (04/26/2002 at 11:44AM -0700), matt massie wrote:
> 
> i THINK i might have a trick that can be helpful for some of your 
> configurations but i'm not sure.  i'm explaining it here in case someone 
> out there wants to try this out.
> 
> on linux, you can enable ip forwarding with a simple command
> # echo "1" > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/ip_forward
> 
> altering this value on your multi-homed frontend will cause it to forward 
> on ganglia multicast traffic to other interfaces.
> 
> if your configuration is like this
> 
>           A
>          / \
>         B   C
>         b1  c1
>         b2  c2
>         ..  ..
>         bn  cn
> 
> if you enable ip forwarding on B and C AND the private IP space on cluster 
> b and c are different, then it might be possible to monitoring everything 
> from A.
> 
> if someone has the time to try this out, can you report on what you found?
> 
> we also need to be sensitive the security ramifications of ip forwarding.
> http://www.linuxsecurity.com/articles/network_security_article-4528.html
> 
> hope it works.  
> 
> -matt
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Ganglia-general mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/ganglia-general

-- 
Chris Elmquist                         mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unlimited Scale, Inc.                  http://www.unlimitedscale.com
St. Paul, MN

Reply via email to