Tentara tidak pernah salah Tentara tidak pernah kalah On 7 October 2016 at 13:45, Marco 45665 [email protected] [GELORA45] < [email protected]> wrote:
> > > ...Mungkin sudah demikian SERBA SALAH - NYA....... > > On 7 October 2016 at 12:29, Yoseph T Taher [email protected] > [GELORA45] <[email protected]> wrote: > >> >> >> >> *Heh......heh......Tentara kan nggak pernah >> salah.......heh.......heh........!* >> >> >> >> ------ Original Message ------ >> From: "'Sunny' [email protected] [GELORA45]" <[email protected]> >> To: >> Sent: Friday, 7 Oct, 2016 At 8:08 PM >> Subject: [GELORA45] FM dismisses ‘pretty diplomat’ furor + Listening to >> the Pacific beat on Papua >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> *RI telah menandatangani dan meratifikasi berbagai konvensi >> internasional, misalnya* : “*Convention against Torture and Other >> Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment”,** sekalipun >> demikian tidak berubah perlakuan TNI dan Polri, teristimewa di Papua dan >> Maluku**. Ini yang dikatakan oleh wakil Salomon di sidang umum PBB >> pada first reply : >> http://webtv.un.org/search/solomon-islands-first-right-of-reply-/5141621665001?term=Iran,%20right%20of%20reply >> <http://webtv.un.org/search/solomon-islands-first-right-of-reply-/5141621665001?term=Iran,%20right%20of%20reply>* >> >> >> http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2016/10/01/fm-dismisses-p >> retty-diplomat-furor.html >> >> FM dismisses ‘pretty diplomat’ furor >> >> - >> >> >> The Jakarta Post >> >> | Sat, October 1 2016 | 09:33 am >> *Nara Masista Rakhmatia* - Tribunnews.com >> >> The Foreign Ministry on Thursday brushed off concerns that Indonesia had >> insulted no fewer than six Pacific Island heads of state, following a >> viral video of a junior diplomat trashing their allegations of human >> rights violations in Papua and West Papua during the recent UN General >> Assembly (UNGA). >> >> Social media users this week have been agog over the UNGA session where >> Nara Masista Rakhmatia, the second secretary at Indonesia’s permanent >> mission to the UN, responded to last Saturday’s speeches of the heads of >> state of Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Nauru, Marshall Islands, Tuvalu and >> Tonga. >> >> “Nara was speaking using the right of reply on Saturday [Sept. 24], >> which was after the heads of state had finished giving their statements. >> She didn’t speak during the session of the heads of state,” ministry >> spokesman Arrmanatha Nasir said. >> >> The 71st UNGA was held in New York from Sept. 19 to 29. >> >> Many viewers of the video of the “pretty young diplomat”, viewed almost >> 200,000 times on Youtube as of Friday afternoon, praised Nara’s response, >> saying it had “checkmated” or “crushed” the heads of state. >> >> Among other things, the Indonesian diplomat said criticism against >> Indonesia amounted to “interference” and encouraged separatism in the two >> provinces. >> >> However, others questioned why the ministry had assigned a lower-ranking >> diplomat to respond to the heads of state, which could be interpreted as a >> deliberate insult to them and their countries. >> >> Furthermore, reports on Friday said Nara was drawing fury from >> “separatists”, who cited repeated and unresolved human rights violations >> against residents of Papua and West Papua. >> >> Evi Fitriani, a lecturer of international law at the University of >> Indonesia (UI), said Indonesia had not violated any convention, “but >> diplomatically there is this rule of reciprocity, that if a head of state >> says something, the response shall come from another head of state” or at >> least from a high-ranking official. >> >> She added it was legally acceptable, “but not diplomatically >> appropriate” for Indonesia to have the second secretary deliver the >> responding statement. >> >> Arrmanatha said Nara’s response was “Indonesia’s position, which has >> been discussed thoroughly” within the ministry. “It doesn’t matter who >> says it. Whoever conveys the message, it is still Indonesia’s position,” >> he said. >> >> For the country’s diplomats, he added, “the unitary state of the >> Indonesian Republic is a fixed price” where interference in Indonesia’s >> sovereignty and separatism is unacceptable. >> >> Hikmahanto Juwana, another international law expert, said it was normal >> for Nara, as a diplomat in the Indonesian delegation, to convey the reply. >> “It was an Indonesian voice,” he said on Friday. >> >> On Monday, Australia’s state broadcaster ABC quoted Solomon Islands >> Prime Minister Manasseh Sogavare as saying at the UN General Assembly, >> “Human rights violations in West Papua and the pursuit for >> self-determination of West Papua [Papua] are two sides of the same coin.” >> >> “Many reports on human rights violations in West Papua emphasize the >> inherent corroboration between the right to self-determination that >> results in direct violation of human rights by Indonesia and its attempts >> to smother any form of opposition.” >> >> Nara said such criticism “only reaffirmed the persistent violation of >> […] the UN Charter by blatantly interfering in the internal affairs of >> other states, violating the sovereignty and territorial integrity of other >> nations.” >> >> The Indonesian government has previously said it is examining 22 cases >> of alleged human rights violations in Papua, three of which it hopes to >> complete by the end of this year. >> >> Critics say the government persistently approaches issues relating to >> Papua with policies that rely heavily on doling out money while ignoring >> human rights abuses. >> >> The alleged failure of Papua’s special autonomy has given rise to >> attempts to support independence movements, particularly from Pacific >> nations. *(vny)* >> >> *++++* >> >> http://www.thejakartapost.com/academia/2016/09/29/listening- >> to-the-pacific-beat-on-papua.html >> Listening to the Pacific beat on Papua >> >> - >> Budi Hernawan >> >> Jakarta | Thu, September 29 2016 | 08:07 am >> [image: Listening to the Pacific beat on Papua] >> Defiance: A Papuan activist shouts slogans during a demonstration to >> commemorate the West Papuan declaration of independence from Dutch rule in >> Jakarta on Dec. 1, 2015. The Police fired tear gas to disperse more than >> 100 Papuan protesters during the rally.(JP/DMR) >> >> In an unprecedented move, seven UN member states from the Pacific raised >> their concerted voices on Papua during the prestigious 71st session of the >> UN General Assembly in New York this week. >> >> Nauru started the intervention by highlighting the issue of human rights >> violations in Papua, followed by a newcomer in the discourse of Papua: the >> Marshall Islands. >> >> Vanuatu, Tuvalu and the Solomon Islands followed suit and went one step >> further by specifically highlighting the issue of the right to >> self-determination for Papuans. Tonga emphasised the gravity of the >> problem and Palau, another novice, called for constructive dialogue with >> Indonesia to solve the Papua issue. >> >> This was a historic moment for us as we have never had such unified >> high-profile intervention when it comes to the issue of Papua at the UN. >> Perhaps the only lone ranger used to be Vanuatu, which tried to break the >> silence of the UN fora. >> >> This week’s debate at the UN General Assembly might remind us of a >> similar but much more colorful debate on Papua at the assembly in 1969, >> when the forum decided to close the chapter on Papua by accepting the >> result of the Act of Free Choice. >> >> If in 1969 some African countries expressed opposition to the assembly’s >> decision to adopt the result of the 1969 Act of Free Choice for Papuans, >> today the Pacific nations are taking the lead. >> >> Indonesia’s response, however, was highly predictable. Repeating the >> slogan of territorial integrity and sovereignty, the government’s response >> unfortunately does not provide us with facts and evidence of the >> improvement in the human rights situation in Papua. >> >> It may be remembered that President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo promised to >> solve the killing of four high-school students in Paniai on Dec. 8, 2014. >> The investigation into the case has been delayed for almost two years and >> we have not seen much progress. >> >> The families of the victims recall that at least eight government >> institutions sent their respective fact-finding team to interview victims >> on the ground and personnel of the Army, the Papua Police, the National >> Police, the Air Force, the Papua Legislative Council, the Witness and >> Victim Protection Agency (LPSK), the Office of Coordinating Security, >> Political and Legal Affairs Minister, the National Commission on Human >> Rights (Komnas HAM). None of these teams, however, has ever published >> their report for public consumption. >> >> Similarly, the dossiers on the Wasior killings of 2001 and the Wamena >> case of 2003 have been pending for more than a decade at the Attorney >> General once Komnas HAM finished its investigation. These were not >> ordinary crimes but crimes against humanity, one of the most serious >> crimes punishable by Indonesian and international law. Unfortunately, both >> Komnas HAM and the Attorney General’s Office have argued over evidence and >> procedure for years. >> >> Komnas HAM insists that it has provided conclusive evidence and has >> followed proper procedure. On the other hand, the Attorney General’s >> Office has argued that Komnas HAM has not met the requirement of a >> pro-justice investigation as investigators did not take an oath as required >> by the Criminal Law Procedures Code. Both institutions have overlooked the >> fact that victims continue to suffer. >> >> Memories are still fresh on the surge in the arrests of Papuan youth >> when they took to the streets to express their opinions in public despite >> a constitutional guarantee of the right to do so. >> >> The Jakarta Legal Aid Institute (LBH Jakarta) documented that at least >> 4,587 individuals, men and women, were arrested by the police for >> expressing their political views in 13 cities, namely Dekai, Fakfak, >> Jakarta, Jayapura, Kaimana, Makassar, Malang, Manado Manokwari, Merauke, >> Sentani, Wamena and Yogyakarta. >> >> While most of the arrestees were released within 24 hours, the >> deployment of police in 13 jurisdictions across the country would not have >> been possible without the blessing of the National Police top brass. >> >> While we were grappling with human rights conditions in Papua, we were >> shocked by the President’s decision to appoint Gen. (ret) Wiranto as the >> coordinating political, legal and security affairs minister. >> >> In February 2003, the UN-sponsored Special Panels for Serious Crimes of >> the Dili District Court, Timor Leste, indicted Gen. Wiranto, then the >> Indonesian defense and security minister and Indonesian Armed Forces >> (ABRI) commander for crimes against humanity in connection with the events >> in Timor Leste in 1999. >> >> As we were yet to recover from the President’s unfathomable choice, we >> were presented with another unprecedented decision when the Indonesian >> Military TNI chief named Maj. Gen. Hartomo to lead the military’s >> Strategic Intelligence Agency (BAIS). >> >> Hartomo was the commander of the Army’s Special Forces (Kopassus) >> Tribuana X unit assigned to Papua when Theys Eluay was murdered. Hartomo >> and six other Kopassus officers were charged with Theys’ murder on >> National Heroes Day in 2001. He and his team were found guilty and >> sentenced to three years in prison by the Surabaya Military Court and >> discharged from the Army. >> >> These all are simple facts that tell us the way our government commits >> to human rights in Papua and elsewhere, which the Indonesian delegation to >> the UN General Assembly describes as “robust and active”. >> ______________________________ >> >> *The writer, who obtained his PhD from the Australian National >> University, lectures in international relations at the Paramadina Graduate >> School of Diplomacy, Jakarta.* >> >> >> >> >> >> > >
