Hi, > - As you can see that the domain redirects to https://tvm.apache.org/. > So hopefully there is no confusion here.
In some cases it does not. e.g. discuss.tvm.ai IMO this is a graduation blocker. > P2: releases > - The PPMC has a well documented release process[1] > that anyone can go and produce a release. > - While we understand that it is good to produce more releases, > hopefully it is not a hard blocker, as the most important thing > for the PMC to be able to make high-quality Apache releases. IMO this is a graduation blocker. A project meeds to make several releases with different release managers. Even if it is well documented only having one release manager is a large risk. If the process is well documented and easy to do then why haven’t you produced more releases? > P2: Docker image > > - These docker images do not contain tvm, instead they contain CI > environment > to set up dependencies(e.g. compilers libraries) for running integration > tests. Then why do they have 40K+ downloads? It also doesn’t explain the version numbers. > - These images are not Apache releases, there is a clear disclaimer > that they are thirdparty and not part of the ASF release[1]. If they are not Apache releases then they cannot use the TVM name. > - The PPMC also clearly understand the need to protect Apache brand, and > clearly differentiate Apache release from thirdparty ones by adding > disclaimers[3] to places when they are referred to. You need to do more than just add a disclaimer. > name that does not contain tvm. Please note again these binaries are only > used for integration test purposes, the community do not intend to > advertise them as Apache releases. Except they are [1] Thanks, Justin 1. https://tvm.apache.org/docs/install/index.html --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
