I've observed that graduation tends to be much easier with a shorter time in incubation. This is across many years but admittedly not that many projects that I have personally been involved with, so YMMV.
Very high level observations: 1. projects that come in with an active community can graduate quickly 2. projects that come in with a small community but are kept on task and actively encouraged to start graduation proceedings can graduate rather quickly 3. messaging around community health being a blocker for graduation can become confusing especially for podlings that have been incubating for a long time because it is hard to attract new contributors in such a state If instead of the long flat readiness checklist we actually had an acceleration program with milestones to get them up and running and out the door in as early as 3-6 mths that it would make an impact. This could potentially be enabled by some tooling initiatives to help close the gaps faster. The community building part, while important for TLP success, shouldn't be a trap that extends incubation, IMO. If a podling is demonstrating the ability to make decisions properly and to get releases out in response to need and/or project growth then shouldn't have to prove much more in order to become TLP. Perhaps community building/health isn't a hard gate even today but the messaging needs to be more clear. Just some thoughts. On Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 2:53 PM Rich Bowen <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi, friends, > > I’m reluctant to speak up, because I know that these kinds of comments > have been received very adversarially in the past, but in light of the > threads on members@, I wonder if there’s an appetite to hear comments, > and maybe make some adjustments as a result. > > Over the past 2 weeks, as a result of the threads on member@, I have been > having informal conversations with people in incubating projects - both > project members and mentors - about projects that appear to me, a complete > outsider, ready to graduate, trying to understand why they are not, and > what can be done to help them get there. I wanted to share some insights. I > hope they are not unwelcome, or taken as criticism, but, rather, as an > attempt to suggest an area where a small improvement or nudge might have > some beneficial results. > > In the conversations with project members, when I’ve asked what it would > take to get you from where you are to graduation, the overwhelming response > was “We’re not sure”, with a side of “we’re waiting for the mentors to tell > us what’s next.” > > In conversations with mentors, I get the opposite answer - we’re not sure > why the project isn’t asking to graduate, we’re waiting for them to take > that step. There have also been a number of answers that don’t seem to line > up with actual Incubator graduation requirements, as I understand from my > rather extensive and exhausting reading over the past 2 weeks. Things about > code quality, number of companies which are part of the PMC, and volume of > commit activity were answers that were common. > > This disconnect is troubling, and I wonder if there’s a way to cross that > gap. > > I know we have a *TON* of data around incubating projects. I know that we, > collectively, have a lot of opinions about what each project needs to do in > order to graduate. I’m at a bit of a loss to understand how that isn’t > communicated to those projects. I see a bunch of dashboards and score > cards, like, for example https://incubator.apache.org/clutch/index.html > (although I was told by a few people that “we don’t use that any more”, > which was confusing, since it says it was updated this morning). I wonder > if we can/should be more proactive in trumpeting to these projects what > they should be doing to get over the finish line. > > Please forgive me if this is already being done (indeed, I think it is!) > but these conversations lead me to believe that it’s not being heard. I’m > looking for ways that we can do proactive, specific, targeted outreach to > projects to help them know exactly what their path to graduation is, in > clear ways that are actionable. I’m certainly happy to do (some of) this > work. I am not currently an Incubator PMC member, but I’m not just trying > to say “you’re doing it wrong” from the sidelines. Rather, I want to know > if and how I can help. > > —Rich > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > >
