I'd be keen to see what results Justin's latest Maturity and Graduation self-assessment AI skills reveal. We possibly need to polish them a little more but then it would be interesting to see whether we could email some kind of summary to podlings each month.
Cheers, Paul. On 2026-11-05 19:50 UTC Rich Bowen wrote: > Hi, friends, > > I’m reluctant to speak up, because I know that these kinds of comments have > been received very adversarially in the past, but in light of the threads on > members@, I wonder if there’s an appetite to hear comments, and maybe make > some adjustments as a result. > > Over the past 2 weeks, as a result of the threads on member@, I have been > having informal conversations with people in incubating projects - both > project members and mentors - about projects that appear to me, a complete > outsider, ready to graduate, trying to understand why they are not, and what > can be done to help them get there. I wanted to share some insights. I hope > they are not unwelcome, or taken as criticism, but, rather, as an attempt to > suggest an area where a small improvement or nudge might have some beneficial > results. > > In the conversations with project members, when I’ve asked what it would take > to get you from where you are to graduation, the overwhelming response was > “We’re not sure”, with a side of “we’re waiting for the mentors to tell us > what’s next.” > > In conversations with mentors, I get the opposite answer - we’re not sure why > the project isn’t asking to graduate, we’re waiting for them to take that > step. There have also been a number of answers that don’t seem to line up > with actual Incubator graduation requirements, as I understand from my rather > extensive and exhausting reading over the past 2 weeks. Things about code > quality, number of companies which are part of the PMC, and volume of commit > activity were answers that were common. > > This disconnect is troubling, and I wonder if there’s a way to cross that gap. > > I know we have a *TON* of data around incubating projects. I know that we, > collectively, have a lot of opinions about what each project needs to do in > order to graduate. I’m at a bit of a loss to understand how that isn’t > communicated to those projects. I see a bunch of dashboards and score cards, > like, for example https://incubator.apache.org/clutch/index.html (although I > was told by a few people that “we don’t use that any more”, which was > confusing, since it says it was updated this morning). I wonder if we > can/should be more proactive in trumpeting to these projects what they should > be doing to get over the finish line. > > Please forgive me if this is already being done (indeed, I think it is!) but > these conversations lead me to believe that it’s not being heard. I’m looking > for ways that we can do proactive, specific, targeted outreach to projects to > help them know exactly what their path to graduation is, in clear ways that > are actionable. I’m certainly happy to do (some of) this work. I am not > currently an Incubator PMC member, but I’m not just trying to say “you’re > doing it wrong” from the sidelines. Rather, I want to know if and how I can > help. > > —Rich > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
