Hi PJ, Jianmin, Ed, and IPMC, Thank you all for the thorough reviews. PJ, thanks for filing #4475-#4479 — we have triaged all five against the RC14 artifacts and confirm they are accurate. Jianmin, thanks for the independent verification and the follow-up question. Ed, thanks for the checklist pass — the LICENSE-binary path nit (licenses/ vs licenses-binary/) is noted as well.
To answer Jianmin's question directly, here is how we propose to handle these items. Context: 0.9.0 has accumulated about a year of changes since 0.8.1-incubating, and this cycle has already been through fourteen RCs, several of which were spent entirely on license and packaging hygiene (source archive cleanliness, ICU attribution, CDDL documentation, upstream enumeration of copied files). The community would very much like to get this body of work into users' hands, so our preference is to publish 0.9.0 from RC14 and address everything found in a fast 0.9.1 follow-up. On the nature of the findings: none of the components involved fall outside Category A/B. The Trino and Bitnami code is Apache-2.0, the ICU license is already reproduced in LICENSE, and the jars missing from the binary LICENSE are ALv2/ASL-1.1/CDDL with their license texts already shipped inside the jars and under licenses/. The same Trino and Bitnami files also went out unattributed in 0.8.1-incubating. In short, the gaps are enumeration and file-header bookkeeping rather than missing or incompatible content — consistent with PJ's own assessment that none of them are blockers. Plan: - If the IPMC agrees the findings are non-blocking, release 0.9.0-incubating from RC14 as-is. - Open the 0.9.1 cycle immediately afterwards: fix all five issues (#4475-#4479) and the LICENSE-binary path correction, together with the bug-fix patches already queued on the 0.9.x branch, and run a short vote cycle so 0.9.1 ships quickly. PJ — you mentioned you may change your vote to +1 if the extra vote is needed; it is, and we would be grateful. Additional reviews from other IPMC members are of course very welcome. Thanks, ConradJam Jianmin Huang <[email protected]> 于2026年11月10日周二 02:59写道: > Hi all, > > I forgot to include the verification details in my earlier +1, so I’m > following up with my checks for 0.9.0-incubating RC14. > > The source and Hadoop 3 archives passed SHA-512 and OpenPGP verification. > The source archive matched v0.9.0-rc14 after applying the release packaging > exclusions. Apache RAT passed for all 33 modules in the default Maven > reactor, and all 104 amoro-common tests passed. > > I also reproduced the source attribution and header findings in #4475–#4477 > and confirmed that the Hadoop 3 archive’s LICENSE omits several bundled > JARs identified in #4479. Could we clarify how these items will be handled > for RC14? > > Thanks, > Jianmin > > On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 13:21:04 +0000, ConradJam via general > [email protected] wrote: > > Hello Incubator PMC, > > The Apache Amoro community has voted and approved the release of Apache > Amoro (incubating) 0.9.0-incubating RC14. We now kindly request IPMC > members review and vote for this release. > > Apache Amoro (incubating) is a Lakehouse management system built on open > data lake formats. > > Amoro community vote (subject “[VOTE] Release Apache Amoro (incubating) > 0.9.0 RC14”, opened 2026-11-02, closed 2026-11-06): > https://lists.apache.org/[email protected]:2026-11 > Result: 3 binding +1 (Congxian Qiu, Xavier Bai, Jinsong Zhou), no +0, > no -1. > > Source release, convenience binaries for Hadoop 2 and Hadoop 3, > signatures and SHA-512 checksums: > > https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/amoro/0.9.0-incubating-RC14/ > > The artifacts are signed with my PGP key (Apache ID: czy006), > fingerprint 2A92 A3A5 865F 6AC0 55FE 7460 0D08 BC5B BE10 2BE7. > KEYS: https://downloads.apache.org/incubator/amoro/KEYS > > Maven staging repository: > https://repository.apache.org/content/repositories/orgapacheamoro-1093 > > Git tag v0.9.0-rc14 (commit 18d12b99d5297dbd0bb4eb72517c4855d75210f6): > https://github.com/apache/amoro/tree/v0.9.0-rc14 > > Note on release history: a previous IPMC vote on RC10 (2026-09-21) > received a binding -1 and is superseded by this vote. All findings from > that thread were addressed and re-verified on the RC14 artifacts: > > - Source archive pollution: RC10 contained 3,119 AppleDouble (._*) files > that broke the build on Linux; the RC14 source archive contains none. > - ICU attribution: LICENSE now credits The ICU Project, documents that > the Flink lookup ByteArrayWrapper.java is derived from ICU4J, and > includes the full ICU license text. > - Source LICENSE gaps: SparkInternalRowWrapper.java (v3.3, v3.4, v3.5), > ThreadLocalCache.java and the Spark parser Scala files are enumerated > with their upstream attributions. > - Binary LICENSE-binary gaps: the CDDL dependencies (activation, > jaxb-api, javax.annotation-api, javax.servlet-api, javax.json, jta) > are documented, and javassist is listed under Apache-2.0. > - Findings from later community votes are also included: embedded > license documentation for PostgreSQL’s bundled ongres SCRAM and > Stringprep components, the dnsjava disclosure, and the Kyuubi JDBC > shaded-jar modification notice (PRs #4456 and #4473). > > One judgment call, disclosed for completeness: xmlenc-0.52 is documented > under BSD-3-Clause, following the license declared in the distributed > artifact’s POM (OSI “BSD License”). The jar itself carries no license > file; the upstream in-repo copyright statement added in 2011 uses a > 2-clause variant. > > The vote will remain open for at least 72 hours and passes with at > least 3 binding +1 votes from IPMC members. > > [ ] +1 approve > [ ] +0 no opinion > [ ] -1 disapprove with the reason > > To learn more about Apache Amoro, please see https://amoro.apache.org/ > > Checklist for reference: > > [ ] Download links are valid > [ ] Checksums and signatures > [ ] LICENSE/NOTICE/DISCLAIMER files > [ ] No unexpected binary files in the source release > [ ] All source files have ASF headers > [ ] Can compile from source > > Validation guide: https://amoro.apache.org/validate-release/ > > Thanks, > czy006 (Conrad Jam) > > – > Best > > ConradJam >
