On Mon, Mar 17, 2014 at 9:38 PM, Jacopo Notarstefano <jacopo.notarstef...@gmail.com> wrote: > It seems to me that the topic of adding the checkpatch.pl script to > Git's source tree has cropped up several times in the past, as > recently as a couple of days ago: $gmane/243607. > > It should be noted that its usage for its sake has been discouraged by > Junio Hamano in $gmane/205998.
In the referenced message, Junio says that he often runs checkpatch.pl on incoming patches. > Also, its use is somewhat controversial > and has led to flames and even a public fork. > > Despite this, I think that git might benefit from a port of > checkpatch.pl. In fact, even Junio had admitted to use part of its > features later in $gmane/205998. > > We could simply use linux's script/checkpatch.pl, but I think a port > is needed for these reasons: > > 1. Git style guidelines are somewhat different and less strict than > their Linux equivalents. Are checkpatch.pl's customization options, such as --ignore, insufficient to make it behave in the desired fashion for git? > 2. Several patch threads bounce back and forth because of style fixes. > A checkpatch script added as a hook could help reduce these and use > more efficiently our time. > 3. As far as I can tell, checkpatch needs to be run from the root > folder of a linux repository clone. Cloning several hundred MBs for a > single perl script looks a little foolish to me. No need to clone the kernel. checkpatch.pl runs fine standalone with the --no-tree option. > So, is there any interest in adding a port of checkpatch.pl to > contrib/? I might work on this as part of GSoC. I still haven't > submitted my application about git bisect (life got in the way!), but > Michael Heggarty remarked in $gmane/242703 that my original idea had > too little meat in it to constitute a good GSoC proposal. > > Cheers, > Jacopo Notarstefano -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majord...@vger.kernel.org More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
