On Mon, 10 Jul 2023 04:24:24 +0200 Denis wrote:
> I'd prefer avoid comparisons with the FSD as it's a different project
> that might or might not have the same set of policies.
i have already offered that analysis as best as i understand it (IIRC on this
same thread) - the FSDG deals only with source code and has "the four freedoms"
as it's policy, and nothing more - anything beyond the four freedoms is
irrelevant or is posted as a warning
so the FSDG is a proper super-set of the FSD criteria ("the four freedoms" plus
more criteria) - therefore, anything which fails an FSD audit is necessarily
unfit for the FSDG; so all of the FSD rejections are relevant to distros
the "List of software that does not respect the Free System Distribution
Guidelines" could list all of those immediately with the suggested liberation
treatment: "none yet known", and ideally go beyond that to suggest acceptable
liberation treatments for each, as they become known
On Mon, 10 Jul 2023 04:24:24 +0200 Denis wrote:
> And the next
> step if we look at the FSD would be to start looking at how similar
> it is, and then discuss FSD policies and so on, in a never ending
> discussion.
yea, like this one :)
i was only suggestion that as an ideal situation, to describe the intention and
utility of "the list" itself - this work-group is far from doing anything
"ideal" yet
