On Sat, 15 Nov 2003, Prof. Tom Wilson wrote: > Stevan Harnad says: > >s> Please remember that most researchers currently search their abstracts >databases >s> and their toll-access journal content databases without the help of any >subject >s> classification taxonomies. This will continue to be the case for the >open-access >s> full-text database, once it grows to a significant size. Journal articles -- >s> especially when they include inverted full-text -- are not, and never >s> were, searched via prepackaged subject classifications or taxonomies >s> or aggregations.
> I think that Stevan is a little too sweeping in his generalisation here. In > the > days before machine searching, pretty well all abstracting journals were > organized according to some subject specific classification scheme: Chemical > Abstracts, Metallurgical Abstracts, Nuclear Science Abstracts are among those > I > searched on behalf of scientists in that dim and distant past. At that time > users certainly relied upon those classification schemes to help them to > reduce > the volume of material they needed to search. I agree completely. But we are now in the days of machine searching, done by the researchers themselves, for themselves, google-style. When search is restricted to the inverted full-text corpus of the annual 2.5 million articles published in the planet's 24,000 refereed journals, there is no need whatsoever to rely on classification schemes. http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#26.Classification > Those classification schemes > continue today in the print versions and online versions generally offer the > possibility of a search by class. Yes, but does anyone bother to use them (online)? > The debate about the cheapness of simplistic > Boolean searching (which puts the costs on the user to disentangle the useful > from the useless) versus the cost (to the producer) of high quality subject > indexing and classification has never been settled - and doubtless never will > be. But one thing is sure: It is irrelevant to the issue of open access, and certainly not something to wait for! Stevan Harnad > ___________________________________________________ > Professor T.D. Wilson, PhD > Publisher/Editor in Chief > Information Research > InformationR.net > University of Sheffield > Sheffield S10 2TN, UK > e-mail: [email protected] > Web site: http://InformationR.net/ > ___________________________________________________ >
