On 18 Nov 2003 at 17:48, Stevan Harnad wrote: > On Tue, 18 Nov 2003, Franklin, Rosemary (franklra) wrote: > .... How do you search nuances? > > I don't know of any evidence that inverted full-text boolean search is > any less effective in one field than another. (Does anyone have any > such evidence?) >
I don't know about hard evidence, but my wife works as a professional indexer in the humanities (all the top scholars ask for her ! She isn't ever short of work) and indexing this style of book makes a joke out of keyword searching or any form of inverted file. It is concepts, not words people want. The same concept is often expressed in different words, or, to take another example: "Major announced in Westminster that Maastricht was totally unacceptable". Is this about Westminster? Majors? The Netherlands? No. Try "British foreign policy" or something similar (depending on the thrust of the book. Belive me, this is a simple example compared to many sociological or philosophical texts and any inverted-file style of 'indexing' would produce complete rubbish. Regards Chris Korycinski St Andrews eprints administrator, Main Library =========================================== phone: external 01334 462302 : internal x 2302 office hours: 9-5 Tue & Wed. 9-12 Th.
