Begin forwarded message: > From: Frederick Friend <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: The Importance of Repository EC- (OpenAire) and RCUK-Compliance > Tags for Mandate Compliance Verification > Date: 5 November, 2012 6:17:35 AM EST > To: [email protected] > Reply-To: Frederick Friend <[email protected]> > > May I underline the importance for all EU and especially UK repositories in > ensuring > compliance with OpenAIRE for harvesting? Whatever political views anybody may > have about the EU, there is no doubt that the EC’s work in supporting > Europe-wide > access to Europe-wide research outputs through repositories has been > exemplary, > and will become even more important as the volume of EC-funded research > increases > under Horizon 2020, and as RCUK begins to implement its new policy. As Eloy > indicates > below, the OpenAIRE team have made significant efforts to introduce > “low-barrier” > compliance/compatibility requirements. As a Reviewer of OpenAIRE for the EC > it has > been a particular sadness for me to witness the reluctance of UK repositories > to become > OpenAIRE-compatible, an action which will benefit UK researchers as well as > all researchers > world-wide. If there are serious difficulties for repositories in introducing > OpenAIRE > requirements, please e-mail me and I shall raise any such issues with the > OpenAIRE team. Thank you. > > Fred Friend > Honorary Director Scholarly Communication UCL > http://www.friendofopenaccess.org.uk > > From: Stevan Harnad > Sent: Sunday, November 04, 2012 6:32 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: The Importance of Repository EC- (OpenAire) and RCUK-Compliance Tags > for Mandate Compliance Verification > > **Cross-Posted ** > > It is extremely important for the success of both funder and institutional OA > mandates worldwide that eprints, dspace and all other repositories be made > compliant with funder harvesting requirements such as those of OpenAIRE (as > Eloy Rodrigues indicates in the passage appended after this message). > > For deposit mandates to work, they need to have a reliable and date-stamped > compliance verification mechanism. > > Plea to repository managers and software developers world-wide: > > This is the time to make sure that your repositories implement the requisite > metadata tags for specifying the funding agency (US, EU or RCUK) as well as > the article's journal acceptance date). > > A system must be designed for ensuring that the mandate will actually be > complied with, which means that there has to be an effective, timely > monitoring mechanism, with swift feedback and consequences in case of > non-compliance. > > That means that immediate-deposit of full-text upon acceptance for > publication has to be monitored continuously, based on authors' ongoing > publication calendar dates not just retrospectively in 4-6-year batches. > > If compliance is instead left to the the latter -- long-delayed retrospective > batches -- then even the talk about a "6-12-month embargo" becomes > meaningless! Embargos can only be observed if publication dates are observed, > and hence if deposits, whether embargoed or unembargoed, are immediate. > That's how deposit-date needs to be integrated into RCUK authors' annual > work-flow, including the all-important date-stamping by the official date of > the journal's letter of acceptance -- not the wildly varying and incalculable > date on which the journal issue actually appears -- which is in turn often > far from the calendar date of publication: as much as a year or more at > times.) > > The EC's and RCUK's mandates have to be integrated with institutional > mandates so as to implement the following 8 shared conditions: > > (1) immediate-deposit (even if access to the deposit is allowed to be > embargoed): > > (2) of the final peer-reviewed draft > > (3) on the date of acceptance by the journal (which is marked by a verifiable > calendar date-stamp) > > (4) and the immediate-deposit must be directly in the author's own > institutional repository (not institution-externally -- central repositories > can harvest from IRs) > > (5) so that immediate-deposit can be monitored and verified by the author's > institution (regardless of whether the mandate is from a funder or the > institution) > > (6) as a funding compliance condition and/or an institutional employment > condition > > (7) and institutional repository must be designated as the sole locus of > deposit for submitting publications for institutional performance evaluation, > funder conditions and national research assessment. > > (8) Repository deposits must be monitored so as to generate rich and visible > metrics of usage and citation so as to verify and reward authors' deposits as > well as to showcase and archive the institution's and funder's research > output and impact. > > An instance of mututally reinforcing funder and institutional policies is the > FRS-FNRS policy in Belgium. > > Best wishes, > Stevan Harnad > > On 2012-11-04, at 12:39 PM, "Eloy Rodrigues" [OpenAire] wrote: > Hi Stevan, > > I agree with the recommendations for compliance-verification for RCUK > that I've seen in another message. > > Regarding OpenAIRE we tried that our infrastructure helps/cooperate (and not > compete) with the network of institutional repositories. We tried to have > very "low barrier" guidelines for compliance (we are now calling > compatibility), basically just requiring identification of the EC project > and access status (Open Access, embargoed, closed) in a "standard" way. > EC funded publications will be regularly harvested from compliant/compatible > repositories. So, authors from institutions with compliant repositories, > just need to deposit on their repository to comply to the EC policy. And > even if an author goes to the OpenAIRE portal to deposit a publication, he > will be re-directed to the repository of it's own institution. > > But unfortunately the number of compliant repositories is still not high > enough (except on some southern countries like Portugal and Spain), and is > particularly low in the UK... > > Best, > Serviços de Documentação > Eloy Rodrigues > Direcção > Campus de Gualtar, 4710 - 057 Braga - Portugal > Telefone +351 253 604 156/7/8; Fax +351 253 604 159 > Campus de Azurém, 4800 058 Guimarães > Telefone +351 253 510 168; Fax +351 253 510 117 > http://www.sdum.uminho.pt | Siga-nos >>
_______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
