Begin forwarded message: > From: "Kornbrot, Diana" <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: Funder Mandate Compliance is for and by Fundees -- not Publishers > Date: 5 November, 2012 8:52:09 AM EST > To: Stevan Harnad <[email protected]>, > "[email protected]" <[email protected]> > > Yes, > Stevan is [as always] absolutely right > Relying on publisher is a BAD idea. > BUT my key suggestions are that in addition to putting full info in depository > “For all articles -- subscription, hybrid-gold, full-gold, embargoed, > un-embargoed) -- the > default option should be for authors to > deposit full-text (author final draft) > immediately on acceptance, with > ACCEPTANCE-DATE tagged > JOURNAL-NAME tagged > FUNDER-NAME tagged > grant-number/name field filled” > > So TWO additional suggestions > > 1. in personal bibliography and on own web site, publication list should > ALWAYS include repository URL. Makes access for other workers > easier & is likely to increase citation. > I routinely put doi URL [not publishers’ URL] and repository URL in URL > field of my reference software] > > 2. where one does NOT have access, include author request of form > “Please can you send me an electronic copy of Ms, doi: xxxxx and/or > give me the URL of copy in your institution open access repository > [see http://www.sherpa.ac.uk/romeo/search.php, > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-access_mandate]. > This encourages use of repositories. > > This is my current policy and a depressing number of good scientists respond > with equivalent of “what is a repository” > Best > > Diana
And repositories should all implement the automated email-eprint-request Button: Sale, A., Couture, M., Rodrigues, E., Carr, L. and Harnad, S. (2012) Open Access Mandates and the "Fair Dealing" Button. In: Dynamic Fair Dealing: Creating Canadian Culture Online (Rosemary J. Coombe & Darren Wershler, Eds.) http://eprints.ecs.soton.ac.uk/18511/ Stevan Harnad > > > On 05/11/2012 12:27, "Stevan Harnad" <[email protected]> wrote: > > On 2012-11-05, at 3:42 AM, "Kornbrot, Diana" <[email protected]> wrote: > > Re: JISC-REPOSITORIES Digest - 2 Nov 2012 to 4 Nov 2012 (#2012-207) > It would be a good idea if publishers were REQUIRED to download > this meta data web download citation is requested > Similarly they should be REQUIRED to download the repository URL > > Diana, I am afraid this is putting the shoe on the wrong foot! > > Funder mandates don't bind publishers, they bind fundees. > > And in general it is a mistake to rely on what publishers (even Gold OA > publishers) do: > > For all articles -- subscription, hybrid-gold, full-gold, embargoed, > un-embargoed) -- the > default option should be for authors to > > deposit full-text (author final draft) > immediately on acceptance, with > > ACCEPTANCE-DATE tagged > JOURNAL-NAME tagged > FUNDER-NAME tagged > grant-number/name field filled > > On no account offload or divide any of this responsibility with publishers, > otherwise > compliance will become and unmanageable, unmeasurable and confused failure. > > (The Wellcome Trust's emphasis and reliance on Gold publishers for compliance > has been responsible for years of OA shortfall for over 50% of annual > Wellcome-funded research. > The Trust is only beginning to remedy this chronic non-compliance. It's > better for other > funders and institutions to learn from the Trust's mistakes rather than to > repeat them at > the cost of still more years of lost OA: OA mandates and OA-provision are a > matter between > the research community and itself. Apart from whatever OA embargoes the > funder of institution > allows, publishers have absolutely nothing to do with it.) > > Stevan Harnad > > > Best > Diana > > > On 05/11/2012 02:26, "Pablo de Castro" <[email protected] > <x-msg://116/[email protected]> > wrote: > > Dear Stevan, > > Thanks for this. > > In fact, stressing the need for the IR network to enhance and harmonise their > metadata in order to be able to provide information for consistently tracking > Open Access outputs may be as important for getting IRs into the main > Research Information Mgt picture as advocating for specifically-formulated > Open Access policies, since their reliability as institutional reporting > tools will thus get significantly strenghtened. > > Besides EU FP7 OpenAIRE Project, the JISC-funded UK RepositoryNet+ (aka the > RepNet) Project http://www.repositorynet.ac.uk/ is also working for providing > new services and tools to the UK repository network. Although currently very > much focused on the so-called RepNet Wave 1 components (ie the R-J Broker > service for automating content deposit into IRs and IRUS-UK project for > delivering COUNTER-compliant cross-repository usage stats), the RepNet is > also aiming to eventually provide a whole set of new repository services, > including DOI-, funder- and grant-related metadata enhancement services, > tools for monitoring funder mandate compliance rates and emphasis on > promoting OpenAIRE-compatibility for UK IRs. See in this regard the "UK > RepositoryNet+: Developing New Services over the UK Repository Network" > poster at http://bit.ly/SQAXbC, to be displayed at the forthcoming Berlin10 > Open Access Conference in Stellenbosch, South Africa. > > The RepNet will also be delivering a comprehensive presentation next Fri at > the UKCoRR annual meeting at Teesside University where the feedback of the IR > manager community on the planned new repository services will be gathered and > discussed. > > > Kind regards, > > > Pablo > > ----- > Pablo de Castro > [email protected] <x-msg://116/[email protected]> > UK RepositoryNet+ Consultant > EDINA > The University of Edinburgh > Causewayside House > 160 Causewayside > Edinburgh EH9 1PR > http://www.repositorynet.ac.uk/ > > > > > On 5 November 2012 01:00, JISC-REPOSITORIES automatic digest system > <[email protected] <x-msg://116/[email protected]> > wrote: > There is 1 message totaling 379 lines in this issue. > > Topics of the day: > > 1. The Importance of Repository EC- (OpenAire) and RCUK-Compliance Tags for > Mandate Compliance Verification > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Date: Sun, 4 Nov 2012 13:32:19 -0500 > From: Stevan Harnad <[email protected] > <x-msg://116/[email protected]> > > Subject: The Importance of Repository EC- (OpenAire) and RCUK-Compliance Tags > for Mandate Compliance Verification > > > > > ***Cross-Posted *** > > > It is extremely important for the success of both funder and institutional > OA mandates worldwide that eprints, dspace and all other repositories be > made compliant with funder harvesting requirements such as those of > OpenAIRE<http://www.openaire.eu <http://www.openaire.eu/> > (as > Eloy Rodrigues indicates in the passage appended after this message). > > For deposit mandates to work, they need to have *a reliable and > date-stamped compliance verification mechanism*. > > *Plea to repository managers and software developers world-wide: * > > This is the time to make sure that your repositories implement the > requisite metadata tags for specifying the funding agency (US, EU or RCUK) > as well as the article's journal acceptance date). > > A system must be designed for ensuring that the mandate will actually be > complied with, which means that there has to be an effective, timely > monitoring mechanism, with swift feedback and consequences in case of > non-compliance. > > That means that immediate-deposit of full-text upon acceptance for > publication has to be monitored continuously, based on authors' ongoing > publication calendar dates not just retrospectively in 4-6-year batches. > > If compliance is instead left to the the latter -- long-delayed > retrospective batches -- then even the talk about a "6-12-month embargo" > becomes meaningless! Embargos can only be observed if publication dates are > observed, and hence if deposits, whether embargoed or unembargoed, are > immediate. That's how deposit-date needs to be integrated into RCUK > authors' annual work-flow, including the all-important date-stamping by the > official date of the journal's letter of acceptance -- not the wildly > varying and incalculable date on which the journal issue actually appears > -- which is in turn often far from the calendar date of publication: as > much as a year or more at times.) > > The EC's and RCUK's mandates have to be integrated with institutional > mandates so as to implement the following 8 shared conditions: > > > (1) *immediate-deposit* (even if access to the deposit is allowed to be > embargoed): > > (2) of the *final peer-reviewed draft* > > (3) on the *date of acceptance* by the journal (which is marked by a > verifiable calendar date-stamp) > > (4) and the immediate-deposit must be directly in the *author's own > institutional repository* (not institution-externally -- central > repositories can harvest from IRs) > > (5) so that immediate-deposit can be *monitored and verified by the > author's institution* (regardless of whether the mandate is from a funder > or the institution) > > (6) as a *funding compliance condition* and/or an *institutional employment > condition* > > (7) and institutional repository must be designated as the *sole locus of > deposit * for submitting publications for institutional performance > evaluation, funder conditions and national research assessment. > > (8) Repository deposits must be monitored so as to generate *rich and > visible metrics of usage and citation* so as to verify and reward authors' > deposits as well as to showcase and archive the institution's and funder's > research output and impact. > > > An instance of mututally reinforcing funder and institutional policies is > the FRS-FNRS > <http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/864-.html>policy > <http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/864-.html%3Epolicy> > in Belgium. > > Best wishes, > Stevan Harnad > > *On 2012-11-04, at 12:39 PM, "Eloy Rodrigues" [OpenAire] wrote:* > > Hi Stevan, > > I agree with the recommendations for compliance-verification for RCUK > that I've seen in another message. > > Regarding OpenAIRE we tried that our infrastructure helps/cooperate (and not > compete) with the network of institutional repositories. We tried to have > very "low barrier" guidelines for compliance (we are now calling > compatibility), basically just requiring identification of the EC project > and access status (Open Access, embargoed, closed) in a "standard" way. > EC funded publications will be regularly harvested from compliant/compatible > repositories. So, authors from institutions with compliant repositories, > just need to deposit on their repository to comply to the EC policy. And > even if an author goes to the OpenAIRE portal to deposit a publication, he > will be re-directed to the repository of it's own institution. > > But unfortunately the number of compliant repositories is still not high > enough (except on some southern countries like Portugal and Spain), and is > particularly low in the UK... > > Best, > Serviços de Documentação > Eloy Rodrigues > Direcção > Campus de Gualtar, 4710 - 057 Braga - Portugal > Telefone +351 253 604 156/7/8; Fax +351 253 604 159 > Campus de Azurém, 4800 058 Guimarães > Telefone +351 253 510 168; Fax +351 253 510 117 > http://www.sdum.uminho.pt <http://www.sdum.uminho.pt/> | Siga-nos > > ------------------------------ > > End of JISC-REPOSITORIES Digest - 2 Nov 2012 to 4 Nov 2012 (#2012-207) > ********************************************************************** > > > > > Emeritus Professor Diana Kornbrot > email: [email protected] <x-msg://116/[email protected]> > web: http://dianakornbrot.wordpress.com/ > Work > Department of Psychology > School of Life and Medical Sciences > University of Hertfordshire > College Lane, Hatfield, Hertfordshire AL10 9AB, UK > voice: +44 (0) 170 728 4626 > fax: +44 (0) 170 728 5073 > Home > 19 Elmhurst Avenue > London N2 0LT, UK > voice: +44 (0) 208 444 2081 > mobile: +44 (0) 740 318 1612 > fax: +44 (0) 870 706 1445 > > > > > > > > > Emeritus Professor Diana Kornbrot > email: [email protected] > web: http://dianakornbrot.wordpress.com/ > Work > Department of Psychology > School of Life and Medical Sciences > University of Hertfordshire > College Lane, Hatfield, Hertfordshire AL10 9AB, UK > voice: +44 (0) 170 728 4626 > fax: +44 (0) 170 728 5073 > Home > 19 Elmhurst Avenue > London N2 0LT, UK > voice: +44 (0) 208 444 2081 > mobile: +44 (0) 740 318 1612 > fax: +44 (0) 870 706 1445 > > > >
_______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
