From: "Eddie Fernandes" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

1. I repeat that I do not claim to be an expert in the field.

2. You have asked me questions about Mr McCrystal which I am not in a position to reply.

3. The vestments are not the original ones. By 1923 the body had shrunk to 1.44m. In 1951 the bones were rearranged to make the body 1.62m in length and new vestments were placed.. Source: http://pweb.sophia.ac.jp/~d-mccoy/xavier/newman3.html#las

4. I was brought up to believe as a child that the body was miraculously in a complete state of preservation and would remain so as long as the Portuguese ruled Goa!

5. I have relayed information about the reports. Please do not attack the messenger, particularly without having read the message!



Dear Eddie,


First of all: My apologies if my post came across as an attack on any messenger. All I did, I believe, is place a few questions. No intent to attack you or anyone else.

Let us see what Mr. McCrystal has to say upon his return from the West Indies

About the "vestments" , IN the Basilica, there are vestments (by themselves) in a glass show case, "purportedly" the ones used by SFX. Those vestments are unlikely to be ones used by a TALL person.

Finally, I'd like to state this: I was NOT brought up to believe that SFX's body would remain in a complete state of preservation (whatever that means) so as long as the Portuguese ruled Goa.

My views on SFX are very simple:

a: The physical state of his body (when I last saw it) does NOT correspond to the normal process of decomposition.

b: SFX's remains are NOT as important as the effect SFX has had on education in India in 2006. Education is one tool that the so-called "lower castes" utilised to overcome the thousands of years of "Caste" enslavement. SFX remains the target of Rt Wing Hindu anger. No prizes to guess why.

In fact, the much touted CM of Goa Manohar Parrikar was quite ready to obliterate Oct 2 (Gandhi Jayanti) & Dec 3 (Feast of SFX) from the list of holidays in Goa.

The Spin about holidays apart, SFX and Gandhi are the two individuals (besides Dr. D.B. Ambedkar) who have built the foundation stones leading to the eventual (I hope) dismantling of the Caste Apartheid in India.

That is why it is important to challenge stories about these two individuals.

For, tiny nuggets of MisInformation are capable of being converted into mega-nuggets of FACTS by those who truly hate SFX, Gandhi, and those who are quite upset at the on-going dismantling of the "caste system".

just my view

jc

_________________________________________________________________
Don’t just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search! http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/


Reply via email to