Hi Gilbert, Mehta's review is the first review of Edna's "Holy Warriors". The "praiseworthy review" what you are talking about is from the publisher's site. As you know, all publishers will carry praise-worthy comments about their product on their site; it is in their interest to sell the book and cover up the cost.
What's wrong in posting reviews which are reviewed in depth by the likes of Pratap Mehta, who is the president and Chief Executive, Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi, author of The Burdens of Democracy and Public Institutions in India: Performance and Design? He is also a prolific contributor to public debates and his columns have regularly appeared in The New Republic, Foreign Policy, The Hindu, Indian Express, Telegraph, Yale Global, and numerous other papers. Am I being non supportive for posting real reviews of Goan authors? Avelino _________ [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is it not curious that a very unflattering review is posted in its entirety on cyber-Goa? And the praiseworthy review is only provided as a link? Is this a Goan supporting another Goan's achievement? _____________________________________________ Do not post admin requests to the list. Goanet mailing list ([email protected])
