Hi George, As usual, you get so base in your response and personal attacks. I hope your post does not reflect where your mind is!
Do I owe Avelino an apology? Yes I did think he wrote the review. And I noticed Mario made the same judgement call, and very likely Victor. I did apologize to Avelino for giving him "credit" for the poor review that he first forwarded / posted. Is it not curious that a very unflattering review is posted in its entirety on cyber-Goa? And the praiseworthy review is only provided as a link? Is this a Goan supporting another Goan's achievement? You and others (except Elisabeth) are attacking me, instead of Mehta's review on the "Holy Warrior." I am only making these points, as you raised the issue; not to confront you, Avelino or a Goan web site. My characterizations of the "Mehta review" that was posted still stands, notwithstanding that it was not written by a Goan. Please spare us your tasteless language. I hope you can write up to your professional standards. Cyber-Goans deserve better. Kind Regards, GL ---- George Pinto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I am a bit surprised that having been caught with your fly open in cyberspace, ..... George --- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > I hope this rather lengthy response will help and enable future reviewers on > the STANDARDS of > good reviewers. For more details and reviewer pitfalls, please read my > three-part article on > the "experience of writing 'On Thin Ice'" which appeared on Goanet. > Kind Regards, GL _____________________________________________ Do not post admin requests to the list. Goanet mailing list ([email protected])
