------------------------------------------------------------------------ * G * O * A * N * E * T **** C * L * A * S * S * I * F * I * E * D * S * ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Enjoy your holiday in Goa. Stay at THE GARCA BRANCA from November to May There is no better, value for money, guest house. Confirm your bookings early or miss-out
Visit http://www.garcabranca.com for details/booking/confirmation. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- --- jose colaco <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > You may wish to direct me to the writings on GoaNet > of "those who lament departure of the Portuguese > following Indian military action in December 1961" > > You may also wish to review the writings ... if > any... and advise IF the lament (if any) is related > to the "departure of the Portuguese " > > OR IF ...the lament is related to some other related > but non sequitur issues. > > I wonder HOW anyone who has lived in Goa can write > that the writings on Goanet represent a lament wrt > departure of the Portuguese following Indian > military action in December 1961. > > There might be a lament ....but is it related to > what Cornel has made it out to be. > > I submit that your above "association" is based on > the Gouveian principle of dys-logik > Mario observes: > Those who read Cornel's original post would know that he was trying to avoid getting into the reasons for the liberation of Goa. This did not stop the learned Dr. Colaco from this amusing and convoluted response to Cornel: > a) Jose starts with a demand to be directed to writings on Goanet that lament the departure of the Portuguese. This suggests that Jose is unaware of such posts. > b) Then Jose pirouettes and says that such writings, "if any", should be reviewed and he should be advised if any lament is "related to the departure of the Portuguese", or some other "non sequitur" issues, whatever THAT means. > c) Then he does another pirouette and says he fails to understand how anyone who has lived in Goa can say that the writings - which Jose previously wanted to be directed to, suggesting he was unaware of them - "represent a lament wrt departure of the Portuguese following Indian military action in December 1961." > d) Then he does YET ANOTHER pirouette and says that there MAY be a lament, but is it what Cornel is making it out to be? Apparently Jose is now suddenly hedging his bets even though he is waiting to be directed to the evidentiary posts and the results of the review he has demanded to be provided with. > e) Finally he "submits" that Cornel has used "Gouveian dys-logik"! > "Dys-logik"??? Hmmmm. The only person with a name remotely like Gouveia on Goanet is known as a paragon of logic:-)) > Isn't it amazing that Jose can start off by asking to be directed to Cornel's sources, and then arrive at a concluding "submission" before Cornel has even had a chance to reply? > Anyone who has followed Jose's verbal ballet would know by now that, among all the sly insinuations and poor spelling, any dis-logic that has been used has not been by the hapless Cornel, who was simply looking for some historical parrallels between the departures of the Portuguese and the British, but by the learned Jose himself. > _____________________________________________ Do not post admin requests to the list. Goanet mailing list (Goanet@goanet.org)