--- On Mon, 3/2/09, Gilbert Lawrence <[email protected]> wrote:

> I noticed there were no responses on Goanet to the recent post, 
> reprinted from the London tabloid, referring to Scarlett's death.  
> Reading the article carefully, the Englishman, who was an on-site 
> factual witness, claims that evidence for murder and specifically the 
> method of murder / homicide is still uncertain. 

Mario observes:

Gilbert,

I think Goanetters may have Scarlett-fatigue and corruption-fatigue and the 
chilling realization that life is pretty cheap in the second most populous 
country in the world, just as it is in the most populous as well.

Date: Mon, 2 Mar 2009 16:41:18 -0800 (PST)
From: George Pinto <[email protected]>

If Goa were a country, it would be termed a "failed state". There is no law and 
order, and the rot starts at the top (the latest Cidade de Goa case being one 
case in a long line of illegal activities). The building, mining, and real 
estate lobbies through their servants (Goan politicians) have sold Goa to the 
highest bidder with the acquiesce of the Goan voter.

Mario observes:

George,

I will agree with you, and only add for the sake of context and perspective, 
that one can also say the same about the rest of India.  I have just returned 
from a trip that included Mumbai, Pune and Jabalpur as well, and this stuff is 
going on everywhere.

One reason that Slumdog Millionaire, which would probably have never seen the 
light of day if not for the Brits who were involved, raised so many hackles and 
resentment in India was that it showed so many disparate and conflicting images 
and facets of India, from the awesome beauty of the Taj Mahal at one end, to 
the grinding poverty and desperation in the slums, to the survival skills of 
the "slumdogs", to the corruption, communal hatred, gangsterism and police 
brutality, all co-existing with the booming middle-class as well as some 
ostentatious and incredible wealth, as some sort of peculiar laboratory 
experiment in functional anarchy.

I am one of those who insists on driving myself wherever I am in India, to 
experience for myself the amazing impatience, self-centeredness for its own 
sake and disregard for anyone else, the national attitude synthesized on 
India's teeming streets, as well as to test and sharpen my own patience and 
survival skills and ability to control a machine under challenging conditions 
and acknowledge that this is the crucible in which I, too, was formed.

Dealing with the rest of the world seems simple by comparison.

We can only watch in bemusement, sometimes horror, sometimes despair, as it all 
unfolds with no clue as to where it will all lead.

On the other hand, I would be remiss if I failed to add that the hospitality is 
incomparable and to bask for a few days in the unconditional warmth of friends 
and family is an uplifting and  rejuvenating experience.








Reply via email to