In this post Marshall Mendonza once again conclusively proves that I have told you Big lies, that I am a hypocrite, and have repeatedly justified violence against Christians. What was important for this tour de force demonstration of my guilt was the use of a special keyboard to copy and paste the same news reports and posts that were posted on Goanet several times before.
Another astounding feat on his part was to perform a Google search to find that a link to the South Asia Terrorism Portal website (of an organization run by the ex-Director General of the Central Reserve Police force, K. P. S. Gill - www.satp.org) was provided by a Hindutva website. That is a fatal blow. Who can deny now that I am a Hindutva sympathizer, and a defender of violence against Christians? Finally, what certifies that he is truly a good man is, despite all the crimes of mine that he has exposed, and shown how bad I am, he generously offers me a conditional apology and grants me a charitable benefit of the doubt. I am not the type of man that deserves this much generosity. I stand by my assertion that Marshall has resorted to militant political activism and circulated at least one inflammatory rumor in this forum. Cheers, Santosh --- On Tue, 3/10/09, Marshall Mendonza <[email protected]> wrote: > > Santosh Helekar: > Regarding holding Christians responsible for the killing of > the swami, I > have never done so, > > Response: > A Big Lie. Refer- > "The riots started in retaliation for the murder of the > Hindu swami and his > associates. Perhaps, this is not a very important and > vital > point.Cheers,Santosh " > Unquote: > Dictionary meaning of retaliation- Reprisal , revenge, > vengence, retribution > http://www.goanet.org/post.php?name=News&list=goanet&info=2008-November/author&post_id=169918 > > Here is another one with bias against christians: > 'How worried do we have to be that sooner or later the > majority of Indians > in Goa and other states will want to assault girls in bars > and kill > Christians?Cheers,Santosh > http://www.goanet.org/post.php?name=News&list=goanet&info=2009-February/author&post_id=173433 > > Santosh: > I absolutely do see a denial because Marshall did not > mention that the swami > was murdered, and the violence started in retaliation for > that murder, as > all mainstream media outlets reported > > Response: > Yet another Big Lie. > "Communal fires continue to rage in Orissa's Kandhamal > district with reports > of more homes and prayer houses being burnt by those > protesting last week's > murder of a Hindu leader, an official said on Tuesday. > The communal violence erupted on the evening of Aug 23, > when Swami > Laxmanananda Saraswati, a member of the Vishwa Hindu > Parishad's (VHP) > central advisory committee, and four others were killed by > suspected Maoist > guerrillas at his Jalespata ashram in Kandhamal." > http://www.goanet.org/post.php?name=News&list=goanet&info=2008-September/author&post_id=166078 > > I had also sent the following post to Goanet but it was not > published nor > rejected even after follow-up. I therefore sent the mail > privately to some > goanetters including Santosh. Refer: > [email protected] > Subject : Fwd: Hindutva Terrorism Bcc > : Santosh Helekar <[email protected]>, > Selma Carvalho < > [email protected]>, > Gabe Menezes <[email protected]>, > Jesus > Fernandes <[email protected]>, > [email protected], > [email protected], > nelsonx rodrigues <[email protected]>, > roland francis < > [email protected]>, > [email protected], > [email protected], > ffernandes dgj <[email protected]>, > [email protected], > [email protected] sat, > Nov 15, 2008 > 06:53 AM > <http://tilmb8.indiatimes.com/mail/h/search?action=view&st=conversation&sq=conv%3a%2221542%22> > > <http://tilmb8.indiatimes.com/mail/h/message?si=38&so=0&sc=22890&sfi=5&st=message&id=21640> > > <http://tilmb8.indiatimes.com/service/home/~/?id=21640&auth=co> > > Hi > > The below posting which was sent to Goanet over 2 days ago > has not appeared > so far. I have enquired twice from the Goanet admin the > reason for the same > but have received no response so far. Neither has there > been any rejection > advice. Until the mystery is solved, I am posting this > privately to some of > you whose email ID's I have in my address book. > > Regards, > > Marshall > ----- Forwarded Message ----- > From: [email protected] > To: goanet <[email protected]> > Sent: Thu, 13 Nov 2008 20:09:57 +0530 (IST) > Subject: Hindutva Terrorism > > Marshall Mendonza : Further a very important and vital > point in the Orissa > violence was that it was not a case of retaliation but pure > aggression. > Santosh:The riots started in retaliation for the murder of > the Hindu swami > and his associates. Perhaps, this is not a very important > and vital > point.Cheers,Santosh > > As per media reports and police and government(BJP/BJD) > information > releases, the Swami was allegedly killed by Maoists who > have also in press > releases claimed responsibility. > http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?sectionName=&id=a81eb464-cf0b-4db0-853f-0ad346c2fe4c&&Headline= > 'VHP+leader's+killing+was+pre-planned' > http://beta.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?sectionName=IndiaSectionPage&id=c475a50a-df27-4cf6-8b5b-c8f49accbc20&&Headline=We+killed+Orissa > 's+VHP+leader%3a+Maoists > http://www.india-server.com/news/maoists-claim-killing-orissa-vhp-leader-4190.html > http://www.odishatoday.com/orissa/laxmanananda_shot_dead_54215867952487513-250808.html > http://www.odishatoday.com/Orissa/Orissa_Govt_orders_judicial_probe_250808-07856475485696.html > http://www.breakingnewsonline.net/2008/08/vhp-leader-swami-laxmanananda-saraswati.html > > Unless there is new evidence which can be conclusively > proved to the > contrary it would be presumptous to believe otherwise. > > Moreover, the CBCI and the Archbishop of Cuttack have > called for a CBI > inquiry condemning the killing. > http://orissaburning.blogspot.com/2008/08/orissa-church-condemns-swamis-murder.html > http://orissaburning.blogspot.com/2008/08/prashant-condemns-swamis-killing.html > > So to go on a rampage and kill christians is certainly not > retaliation but > raw aggression. > > Regards, > > Marshall > > > Santosh: > I believe that people must also never accuse somebody who > merely disagrees > with them and their activities, of justifying violence or > being an apologist > for, or sympathizer or supporter of, violent extremists or > their ideology. > Response: > All crap. Height of hypocrisy. Here are some of the > adjectives used by > Santosh against me which do not embellish his arguments or > enhance hie > reputation in any way - 'militant political activist', > 'rumour mongerer' > just because I disagreed with him. > > Here is evidence that Santosh relies on fringe hindutva > websites for his > information. Refer- > *Contact Addresses and tel/fax/e-mail addresses of OVERSEAS > FRIENDS OF BJP, > Websites of Pro - Hindu Authors & Columnists, > Other Hindu & India related > Organizations* > > South Asia Terrorism Portal (SATP) - from the Institute for > Conflict > Management (ICM) > http://www.icm-satp.com/ > > <http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?sectionName=&id=18c5fe69-1734-4743-a046-34307b812860&ParentID=25c54a9f-489d-48a2-bd2a-9581e13ded56&Headline=Orissa+Govt+asked+for+report+on+violence> > > http://209.85.175.132/search?q=cache:nyEFYYa7A28J:www.hinduunity.com/links.html+satp-hinduunity&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=in > > In conclusion, however, I would grant Santosh the benefit > of doubt as he > has generally been fair and balanced, barring the few > exceptions of late. > And I respect him for this. I accept his explanation and > would like to > believe that when he used the word retaliation, he did not > realise or > understand its import or connotation and did not mean to > justify or condone > the violence against christians as I understood it taking > his words at face > value. > > On my part, I apologise, if I have inadvertently, in any > way used harsh > words or hurt the feelings of Santosh or anyone else in the > passion of the > debate. I treat the debate as a debate and nothing more. > > Regards, > > Marshall >
