Hello,

Maxim Cournoyer <[email protected]> skribis:

> I worry that having such a tag would encourage witch hunting, which
> would definitely be a bad vibe to have in our community.

I think we should stop with the “witch hunting” analogy.  If anyone is
hunting, that’s the dominant pro-LLM group; if anyone is a witch, that’s
those doing what they can to maintain their craft and autonomy.

> An honest, direct question to the author and a gentle approach would
> seem best to me.  Of course if the same person keeps disregarding the
> rule, there can be an escalation, ultimately a ban.

The problem is that it creates a toll on human reviewers.  Without a
clear message that LLM-produced pull requests are not accepted at all,
volunteer time will be wasted kindly asking the author whether they’re a
robot—kinda like Cloudflare’s challenge, but made by humans.

Volunteers ought to be entitled to just close pull requests that look
LLM-generated.  The onus should be on the submitter.

This is a bad vibe, but the volunteers dealing with this are not the
ones to blame; enabling the weakening and rejection of GCD 008 is what
brought us here.

Ludo’.

Reply via email to