Hi, Nguyễn Gia Phong <[email protected]> skribis:
> I've merged https://codeberg.org/guix/guix/pulls/12143 > to broadcast this message. Perfect, thanks for doing that. > I would get if if by _weakening_, you referred to the removal > of the following clause > > On 2026-05-15 at 17:19+02:00, Ludovic Courtès wrote: >> Software where the majority of commits were authored >> or co-authored by genAI **will not be packaged in Guix**. > > but this does not seem to be what is discussed in this thread. Yes, that’s what I was alluding to, and I agree this has to do with the other thread (which talks about what to package) rather than with this one. Sorry for the confusion. >> The problem is that it creates a toll on human reviewers. >> [...] volunteer time will be wasted kindly asking the author >> whether they’re a robot—kinda like Cloudflare’s challenge, >> but made by humans. >> >> Volunteers ought to be entitled to just close pull requests that look >> LLM-generated. The onus should be on the submitter. >> >> This is a bad vibe, but the volunteers dealing with this are not the >> ones to blame; > > I strongly request the retraction of these statements, > especially when they come from the project's founder and one > of very few developers of the critical parts of the Guix. > Per my understanding, they are normalizing throwing insults > at contributors if they did not submit a LLM-generated patch. I didn’t think it would come out as an insult, so please accept my apologies for it. My goal, based on recent experience dealing with this, was to illustrate the imbalance that I see here: as a volunteer I might spend time reviewing a request that was produced by a robot, with no human effort. It’s not unreasonable to think there will be more of these, not out of bad faith, but because people might be unaware of our expectations. > Code of conduct aside, I think it's basic decency to communicate > with each other like human beings. How do you feel I go around > accusing your patches of being generated by LLM without even > talk to you? I very much agree with you: we must communicate with one another. The problem is that in the extreme case there might be nobody to communicate with apart from an LLM handling the pull request. This could easily drain scarce volunteer attention—as happened to me. That’s the risk that triggered the statements I made. But I really hope that you are right, that my message was excessively aggressive, and that we can keep assuming good faith and ask the submitter when in doubt. Let’s just do that. Thank you for your message, and apologies again for unnecessary harshness on my side. Ludo’.
