Thanks Marty. I will add the following to R14 - It must allow the resource to be downgraded to an earlier version which new properties introduced by this project were not defined.
-Elaine Martin Rattner wrote: > I will be out of town on Thursday and cannot attend the open CLARC meeting > this > Thursday for review for Failover File System Monitoring. > > As a CLARC member, I have no objection to approving this project for > inception. > I have only one comment on the requirements specification: > > Requirement R14 says: "Must support resource upgrade." > > I would draw your attention to CR 6770905, in which a problem was encountered > in > attempting to downgrade from version 6 to version 5 of SUNW.HAStoragePlus. > This > problem can be avoided by the implementation of the Validate method. When > you > introduce a new property, the Validate method should not error-out if the > property is found to be non-existent in the resource type; instead it should > just skip that property and continue with the validation. (This might occur > when the resource is downgraded to a lower version of the resource type.) > This > would be applicable to your two new properties described in R4 and R5. > > Note, I have sent a copy of this message to Elaine Ding, the author of the > requirements spec. > > --Marty > > > On 02/09/09 00:32, Steve McKinty wrote: > >> Hi all, >> >> The CLARC inception review for Failover File System Monitoring will be held >> on Thursday February 12th, at 9:00am US/Pacific. The specification is not yet >> avaiable on an external website, if anyone would like a copy please reply to >> this post and I will send it directly (small PDF document). >> >> The details for the conference call can be found at >> http://wiki.genunix.org/wiki/index.php/CLARC >> >> This is an open meeting, anyone is welcome to attend. If you have questions >> that you would like us to discuss in the meeting it would help if you could >> post them as replies here, so that the project team has time to evaluate them >> before the meeting. >> >> Thanks >> >> Steve >> > _______________________________________________ > ha-clusters-discuss mailing list > ha-clusters-discuss at opensolaris.org > http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/ha-clusters-discuss >
