Just because science hasn't discovered 100% of everything yet doesn't mean it 
doesn't exist. 

I don't ascribe to supernatural or 'metaphysical' explanations simply because 
they're indistinguishable from simply making things up.

-William

 

 


 

 

-----Original Message-----
From: David A. Jewell <[email protected]>
To: The Horn List <[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, Jul 12, 2010 11:11 am
Subject: Re: [Hornlist] About those brass playing robots....


From:  "[email protected]" <[email protected]>

Nevertheless, in medicine and psychology, things like emotion are  quantified 

and measureable. They exist in the real world. They aren't  supernatural. Our 

emotions are not some magic pixie dust. They are  products of our brains. They 

can be measured in an MRI.



Valkhorn, I have to disagree. Yes we can know that this heartache is bigger 
than 



one we have experienced before, or that this thrill of achievement after a 

particularly difficult concert is successful is deeper than others we have had, 

but how can you specify a quantity of hate, a specific amount of disdain, or a 

specific quantity of love?  They can measure which areas of the brain are used 

when experiencing specific emotions, but no one has ever stated they can 
measure 



the depth and degree of the emotions being experienced. In other words, they 
can 



know that the subject is experiencing the emotion more intensely, but no one 
has 



yet come up with an emotional thermometer which measures how many degrees of 

whatever we are experiencing.  I happen also to believe that there are aspects 

to humanity that can touch the "supernatural"  if that's the best word to use 

for something that we cannot understand but can see its effects. One other 
point 



I would like to make, if our emotions are so quantifiable, then can you point 

out where science has identified which emotions to experience in reaction to 

specific stimuli?  Very few humans share the same degree of depth of reaction 
to 



a specific stimulus, or even the same emotion, save for those that share an 

artistic experience. For me, to say that emotions are measurable or can be seen 

on a medical test is a little premature to what has been done.  





elsewhere valkhorn wrote:

I would strongly disagree. From what you've described, it would  have to yield 

an emergent property. In other words, something that is  more than the sum of 

its parts. 



I don't believe that can exist  in the human mind. 



Again I have to respectfully disagree.  If "Synergy" can exist in other areas 
of 



the body, namely where two chemicals are introduced into the body each having a 

known specific amount of effect, say on the ability of a muscle to contract,and 

the end result is more than the calculated sum of effect that would be 
expected, 



it is said to be synergistic.  I believe that this can exist in our minds - how 

else to explain someone like me who is an average abled player but who has 

experienced instances where I rose far above my normal results because I 
reached 



into myself and allowed myself to experience my emotions in conjunction with 
the 



music I was playing and produce a synergistic result.  This was a subconscious 

mental action, but still one that was controlled by my brain.  I only wish that 

I could find the time to make that a standard of how I perform.  





in the end, Valkhorn, I find myself pretty much on the side of the fence that 

believes in emotions as that part of humanity that helps us reach beyond the 

mundane in out lives, and makes life what it is. I also don't believe that they 

can yet be accurately and specifically quantified or measured, just gauged to a 

rough level.  I also believe that if music making made emotional content just 

another factor to learn like dynamics or phrasing, then it would lose its 

individuality and become very unworthwhile.  Please take this as my hopefully 

simple statement of my opinion in reaction you what you have said  



Paxmaha





      

_______________________________________________

post: [email protected]

unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com


 
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to