I can't agree at all. Why? Because how do you teach something to another that is somehow a religious or spiritual experience? How can you possibly define it? How can you transfer something that is undefinable? Defining it that way is about as useful as glow in the dark sunglasses.
If we were discussing Biology or Physics or a real science (even in terms of pedagogy) this would be simply inexcusable. It would be about the same level of precision as astrology or psychic powers. But, there's no reason why we can't treat Horn playing and Music as a real science. It exists in the real world. It is quantifiable. The better we understand it, the better it will become. Nevertheless, in medicine and psychology, things like emotion are quantified and measureable. They exist in the real world. They aren't supernatural. Our emotions are not some magic pixie dust. They are products of our brains. They can be measured in an MRI. If you are able to define musicality you are able to better understand it's effects on human emotion. You are better able to teach it. Someone who can't even define it and resorts to mysticism is someone to me who either really doesn't know what it is (is living by intuition) or is unable to even figure out what he himself is doing. Saying something is religious or spiritual is saying that it isn't understandable. Why bother learning anything about it at all if you have that attitude that it is unknowable anyway? -William -----Original Message----- From: Steven Mumford <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Sun, Jul 11, 2010 7:23 pm Subject: Re: [Hornlist] About those brass playing robots.... Well, I would strongly disagree. Of course playing music IS spiritual and/or religious or whatever other term you would prefer for expressing the inexpressible. Otherwise, why would we bother to do it? For the joy of reproducing some notes in a mechanical fashion? Well, some people get some thrill out of that sort of thing. The music that transports me to the other dimension doesn't just speak to my brain, it speaks to my whole body, my soul and to every unexplained particle in the universe. I can appreciate the fountain too, but it's the fairies that make it worthwhile. This is not to insult the human brain, but the brain is so much more than a bucket full of cells with a current running though it. That's just zombie food. If your music is only controlled by your brain, you're just scratching about 10 feet above the surface. The mind IS infinite and it does not obey the laws of physics as currently understood. BTW, I had occasion to own, for a short while, a reproducing grand piano made in the 1930s. Like a player piano, but it also reproduces dynamics, pedaling, touch etc. About as realistic as you can get to a live performance. I believe there's a recording out there of Percy Grainger playing the Grieg Piano Concerto (recorded long ago on reproducing piano) with a modern live orchestra. _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
