I have very thick skin. I usually have contrary opinions to most people and I'm used to it by now. I seriously don't consider that I've been flamed too badly (and I have no blisters). Frankly, no one has really provided a good enough case against my argument to my own satisfaction - and they won't until they can provide something concrete besides feelings and mumbo-jumbo. I've tried to defend myposition as much as possible and I've realized that it's just not goingto be accepted. It's against the established norm. It's far too out ofthe box. When you go against anopinion that's deeply rooted in emotion and based on knee-jerkreactions, you'll get knee-jerk reactions.
I'm well aware that the opposition to my ideas are based in a deeply rooted philosophy about music (and the arts in general). I simply disagree completely. I've been able to become a musical player in spite of having a completely different opinion and I get by just fine. I'm not a professional horn player and probably never will want to be one. However, that doesn't mean I'm a terrible player. However, from my background, I never learned anything by 'feeling'. I learned by figuring it out. When I play, I do not pour emotions into the music. Yet, I'm able to be a musical player and I'm able to trigger emotional responses from whatever audience is listening. I'm very calculated in what inflections I use, dynamics, phrasings, breath marks, etc. and where. I have a different approach, and yet I'm able to achieve the results I want. Sometimes a contrary opinion, in spite of it advocating a method which does work, is going to be met with extreme prejudice. Either way, the discussions over, and from now on I'm keeping my mouth shut. -William -----Original Message----- From: christopher Griffin <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Tue, Jul 13, 2010 9:43 am Subject: [Hornlist] William William, you have been flamed so much and you have deserved every blister you might have gotten as a result! Bravo to all the big guns who tackled this issue so beautifully. Especially Wendell! William said: "In other words (and I've said this how many times now?) you can have that feeling all you want, but it does no good to teach it because you can't teach it, and it does no good to really progress playing and progress music because you might as well be talking about magic purple monkeys or the ether theory or something." ***************************** The doctrine of the affections, also known as the doctrine of affects, or by the German term Affektenlehre (after the German Affekt; plural Affekten) was a theory in musical aesthetics popular in the Baroque era (1600–1750). It derived from ancient theories of rhetoric, and was widely accepted by late-Baroque theorists and composers. The essential idea is that just one unified and "rationalized" Affekt should be aimed at by any single piece or movement of music, and that to attempt more was to risk confusion and disorder. According to the "doctine of the affections" there are three pairs of opposing emotions that make six "affects" all together: love/hate, joy/sorrow, wonder/desire. ****************************** The philosophical writings of Plato and Aristotle (c. 350 BC) include sections that describe the effect of different harmoniai on mood and character formation. For example, Aristotle in the Politics (viii:1340a:40–1340b:5): But melodies themselves do contain imitations of character. This is perfectly clear, for the harmoniai have quite distinct natures from one another, so that those who hear them are differently affected and do not respond in the same way to each. To some, such as the one called Mixolydian, they respond with more grief and anxiety, to others, such as the relaxed harmoniai, with more mellowness of mind, and to one another with a special degree of moderation and firmness, Dorian being apparently the only one of the harmoniai to have this effect, while Phrygian creates ecstatic excitement. These points have been well expressed by those who have thought deeply about this kind of education; for they cull the evidence for what they say from the facts themselves. (Barker 1984–89, 1:175–76) Aristotle continues by describing the effects of rhythm, and concludes about the combined effect of rhythm and harmonia (viii:1340b:10–13): From all this it is clear that music is capable of creating a particular quality of character [ἦθος] in the soul, and if it can do that, it is plain that it should be made use of, and that the young should be educated in it. (Barker 1984–89, 1:176) ***************************** One area of disagreement going back to the origin of the term tonality is whether tonality is natural or inherent in acoustical phenomena, whether it is inherent in the human nervous system or a psychological construct, whether it is inborn or learned, and to what degree it is all these things (Meyer 1967, 236). A viewpoint held by many theorists since the third quarter of the 19th century, following the publication in 1862 of the first edition of Helmholtz's On the Sensation of Tone (Helmholtz 1877), holds that diatonic scales and tonality arise from natural overtones (Riemann 1872, 1875, 1882, 1893, 1905, 1914–15; Schenker 1906–35; Hindemith 1937–70). ******************************* Besides any of this, you can use music to teach feeling! Music/Art are the most useful tools to getting people in touch with their emotions. Many students are very in touch with their emotions. Even if they are, it is up to the music teacher to help them find/understand their feelings so that they might use music combined with their emotions to express themselves. However, in teaching, time is so limited. Some students don't even know how to laugh...where do you begin? The saying "if you can sing it, you can play" comes to mind. Well, if you can feel it you can learn to express it. Sure sometimes the results are only imitation but over time you might start to really feel something. This is difficult and hopeful (impossible sometimes) but worth the effort. Let's face it, most students struggle so much with the horn that they hardly get the chance to play the correct notes, let alone express themselves in a sophisticated way on the instrument. At the very least, these students can hopefully enjoy fun or stress relief from playing the horn in band or orchestra. There are many emotional levels to experience in music. As you said science has worked to explain so many things in our world. In time, science will answer all of your previously posted questions but it may be long after it will make any difference to any of us here. All the best! C. Griffin _________________________________________________________________ The New Busy is not the too busy. Combine all your e-mail accounts with Hotmail. http://www.windowslive.com/campaign/thenewbusy?tile=multiaccount&ocid=PID28326::T:WLMTAGL:ON:WL:en-US:WM_HMP:042010_4 _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
