On Jul 13, 2010, at 10:00 AM, [email protected] wrote: > From: Hans Pizka <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: [Hornlist] William > To: The Horn List <[email protected]> > Message-ID: <[email protected]> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1 > > Hello Christopher, > > Williams error is it, that he thinks emotions & feeling must be > taught. He doesn?t understand it. May-be he has no idea what > caressing means, what love means. > > Emotions & feelings grow from early childhood to the good, if the > environment is emotional & not just technically perfect. Or it grows > to the oposite side, the hatred & the discrimination. And the > emotions grow by experience as knowledge grows by reading & > experimenting. But that is another field. Understanding & feeling > music grows gradually also by listening & by playing oneself. But > both require to develop a certain order in the brain - like in a > schrank: main files, group files, subgroupfiles, single files to > escape the chaos. > > And to the feelingless technicians again: we had them enough in > history & we have them today, beginning with the statistic. I repeat > it here, we are degraded to numbered facts only, far from real > humans, far from respected individuals. It is not only the state, > but the bureaucracy (!) , the guys & girls in the offices, who dont > care a single cent about the individual. It is a very dangerous > situation indeed. If the state needs money, it cuts here & there, no > matter what happen. But the bill is not paid yet. Humans will rebel > sooner or later. Just look back into history. > > So we need more visionaries, who still remain humans with all the > feelings. We are victims of the "roboted time" already, not just in > music.
What a great post, Hans. Maybe your best ever. Where i live here in Silicon Valley, we have a lot of people who spend their lives looking to create reality in their cubicles. Some of these people are some of the most socially and emotionally challenged people i know, but they are trying to create artificial realities and 'intelligence' to sell to the rest of the world. I find it rather sad, as well as absurd. My best students have been the ones who grew up in an environment like the one you describe. Unfortunately, there are many others who continue to look for happiness and salvation in numbers, tests, computer code and statistics. There are, however, a lot of people in the scientific community, which has been a big part of this area over the years, who find a complementary part of their life in music. That is more of what I grew up with. I do NOT include them in this modern version of looking for meaning in all the wrong places. Some of my adult 'techno' students are really fun to teach and they enjoy being amateur musicians and being able to perform in the many adult orchestras around here. I always ask my students about the things they do in their lives. Not as some sort of test or being nosy, I just like to see what I am dealing with, and over the many years and students, certain patterns do appear. The ones who are preoccupied with tests and filling their lives with 'things to do' are usually the hardest to get to just enjoy themselves and their playing. This really gets in the way of finding the inner meaning and expression in what we play. Some people think that if you can put a formula or some numbers on things that you can succeed, but often they do not know what 'success' is. We live in a culture that seems to value competition over involvement, quantity over quality, and 'success' in terms of money instead of enlightenment. School bands are now run like the football teams and competitions are the big thing. The irony is, the kids would be fine with just the music, and many quit when the bands get too caught up in just winning. Personally, i still remember days from my childhood when i just rode my bike with my friends for hours and hours and one day when i just sat in various places on my block while i flew my old blue kite. I remember my pets and football and baseball games with my friends and family. There was also that raft we built when i was ten that we took around a lake in Oregon. The sad thing is, I have students who have never done any of these things, unless it is hyper-organized. And usually there is some kind of contest or scoring involved. I know people have railed against this 'conformity ' since the 50s, but it is getting worse. Video games don't help. Hours in front of TVs and computers don't help. My best and happiest students took those bike rides and didn't take SAT classes so they could have 'perfect' scores. William, i would be glad to work with you sometime on the net if you like. Then maybe i would know where you are REALLY coming from. No charge. Thanks Hans, Wendell For info about my book, DVDs, and live video chat horn lessons, see my web site at www.wendellworld.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
