I have a suggestion for Enblend & Enfuse - how about if you could tell them 
to raise the minimum blending level used in the multi resolution spline 
blending?

Currently, you can limit the maximum number of levels but there's no way to 
limit the MINIMUM. If you could tell it "never use levels smaller than 
this", it could repeat / "clamp" the smallest level to this value for any 
finer details that would normally use a smaller blending level.

I think the result would be a smooth gradient also for the finest details. 
I know this could introduce ghost effects for non-perfect matching images 
but it would also hide the seam, eliminating ugly effects for images that 
are perfectly stitched but differ too much in lighting or focus.

Perhaps we could change its behavior when using negative numbers? Are 
anyone really using negative numbers? Frankly, I don't quite understand 
what negative numbers are good for. They don't do what I'm after anyway.

Here are two problematic examples which I suspect a minimum blending level 
of 6 or so could amend: (small crops of ugly details)

Example 1:
http://www.elmuseum.se/temp/stitchseam1.jpg

Enblend of several focus stacked images (pre-fused in Enfuse) facing the 
wall in a narrow passage in an old water tower. I missed a few spots when 
shooting the focus stack so some unsharp parts have to be used in the final 
panorama. The sharp seam makes it look like there's a diffuse plastic film 
hanging some distance from the wall.

Example 2:
http://www.elmuseum.se/temp/stitchseam2.jpg

Composited nadir shot of the floor in a pitch black culvert. Enblend output 
of several long exposures using flashlight. I usually take a couple of 
nadir shots with the panohead visible and then a final shot with the tripod 
moved, to fill in the center hole where the tripod and panohead was. I 
pre-stitch this to create the nadir shot which is later stitched with the 
rest of the images. Since I had to keep my foot on one of the tripod legs 
for the final shot, I was restricted in how far away I could reach when 
sweeping the flashlight. Therefore that image has a more narrow angle 
between the ground and the flashlight (and the camera) than any other 
images, giving the muddy ground a specular reflection which becomes 
disturbing when stitched into the other shots. Even though I counteracted 
this a lot through Lightroom exposure adjustments, blending layers of 
different shots and passing them through Enfuse, it is still "glossy" below 
a prominent diagonal seam.


Best regards
John Eklund, Sweden

Some of my work:
http://www.elmuseum.se/panorama/panorama.html?pano=daglosen_lokstall_1.xml
http://www.elmuseum.se/panorama/panorama.html?pano=gasklocka4_1.xml
http://www.angkraftverket.se/panorama/

-- 
A list of frequently asked questions is available at: 
http://wiki.panotools.org/Hugin_FAQ
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"hugin and other free panoramic software" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/hugin-ptx/01b741cc-d74b-48c6-9bc3-1f0d2d9d792e%40googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to