Just occurred to me that hydrogen could autoload kits! used kit is in the pattern, right? its a xml tag including the name.
so why can't be just autoloaded? I found 2 possible problems: 1- you don't have installed that kit. SOLUTION: just show a warning and offer to install it from repo. 2- you use a pattern with one kit and another pattern with a different kit. SOLUTION: show a warning and offer to continue with current kit or switch to new. this approach can be implemented parallel to tag/alias solution, they both can coexist. what do you think? mussol Missatge de Przemysław Sitek <el.pesc...@gazeta.pl> del dia dl., 27 d’abr. 2020 a les 23:36: > > Hi! > > > > >> 3- Patterns should be kit agnostics. Sometimes I discard a pattern > >> because it sound bad and later I found is because it was created with > >> another kit so elements get mixed. This shouldn't happen. Also it > >> would be great to be able to import midi directly. I know this have > >> been discussed in the past and maybe is a good time to start. > > > > Yes, this has been discussed in the past. But without any result. Do > > you have any good idea how to implement this? We discussed a tag-based > > system, but this was years ago and nobody had since an interest in > > implementing > > this. > > We could use MIDI note numbers to match kit pieces in different drumkits, but: > > 1. Outside some most common kit pieces (bass drum/snare/hihat), drum kits may > or may not be „compatible”, eg. what happens if we load pattern with cowbell > into kit that doesn’t contain cowbell? > > 2. Many (most?) drum kits in Hydrogen repo do not have MIDI note numbers > assigned at all. Bummer! > > Best regards, > Przemek > > _______________________________________________ > Hydrogen-devel mailing list > Hydrogen-devel@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/hydrogen-devel -- ======================== ^ ^ O O (_ _) muzzol(a)muzzol.com ======================== No atribueixis qualitats humanes als ordinadors. No els hi agrada. ======================== "El gobierno español sólo habla con terroristas, homosexuales y catalanes, a ver cuando se decide a hablar con gente normal" Jiménez Losantos ======================== _______________________________________________ Hydrogen-devel mailing list Hydrogen-devel@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/hydrogen-devel
