Agreed... but not convinced that the CJK tables do not have an "intended" use. At least the T/SC table is already actively being used by a couple of domain operators.
Edmon ----- Original Message ----- From: "Erik Nordmark" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Edmon Chung" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > If this is so, why dont we also put in the mapping tables created by the CJK > > communities respectively on their particular issues (including jpchar > > hangulchar and tsconv) into the Stringprep respository? Nameprep will not > > need to choose these tables, while people can get the information from those > > valuable discussions at a common place and decide whether to implement it > > themselves. > > The tables currently in stringprep are only those that are going > be used by an IETF standard. Thus as more IETF standards do I18N > and need more stringprep profiles, stringprep might need additional > tables. > > But adding tables to stringprep before there is an intended use for them > seems problematic - the IETF would have no criteria for what tables would > or would not go into stringprep. > > Erik > > >
