Wei Chuang wrote in
 <caafswk059k5pmp3wkhztjwmdstxaaggnuztf+jomb3kv6rf...@mail.gmail.com>:
 ...
 |I looked for currently available OpenSSL signature algorithms and don't see
 |composite PQC.  I do see support for ML-DSA algorithm in OpenSSL 3.6.4:

You build it yourself.

  ...
 |I checked with Viktor Dukhovni at Openssl, it sounds like it will not be
 |supported in the near term.  Another way to build out support for composite

But i am here to say one thing.
What is "near term".  If you quote this person that i have a very
high opinion of, i would ask for including your exact question in
order for me and others to interpret your interpretation "near
term" of the answer of Mr. Dukhovni (to whom i did not speak
myself) correctly.

So until there is exact term, given the plain wrong technical
statements we (to be exact: i) have heard here in the past,
i believe you asked Mr. Dukhovni whether the NIST 2027 candidates
will be included "before or around Halloween 2026", and got an
according honest answer that fits that bill you have asked for.

 |PQC signatures is to use the multi-algorithm signature support in DKIM2.  I
 |think some folks suggested that early on.  Regarding RSA vs Ed25519, sure,
 |if we use DKIM2 multi-signature support, supporting it should also be
 |straightforward.

Seems to me, that is, how Mr. Kucherawy if i recall correctly put
it, and to make this crystal clear for the spectator, exactly one
thing: "garbage in, garbage out".

The technical question is exactly one: how to create an upcoming
standard post-quantum safe, and in a way that fits the standard as
such.  And: we talk about signatures that live 10 days or
less, placed in a per-se unencrypted data format.

This is not a decrypted OpenSSH or TLS session that is saved away,
for a possible later decryption attempt, once quantum computers of
according power get available at a cost the interested party can
afford.  It is a signature on a cleartext data format that lives
for 10 days or less, the breaking of which is very very likely
meaningless anytime before ISO 8601 2030-04-24T11:20:17Z, but very
likely even thereafter, for at least some time.

So given the massive advantages of the candidates of the 2027 NIST
consideration, not only for this very task we talk about here, the
question to Mr. Dukhovni, i am guessing, and i am guessing right,
should have been a different one.
Resulting in a different answer.

Btw in private i talked about an at maximum mediocre personality
show regarding the IETF email environment.  Technical its worse.
I can give plenty of examples.

Thank you.  Have a nice Sunday evening.

--steffen
|
|Der Kragenbaer,                The moon bear,
|der holt sich munter           he cheerfully and one by one
|einen nach dem anderen runter  wa.ks himself off
|(By Robert Gernhardt)
_______________________________________________
Ietf-dkim mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to