Peter, I think that by now I've made my points and defended them adequately and that there is little more to be acheived by continuing a public, and largely personal, point-by-point argument. If you want to continue this in private mail I'll consider it. The simple fact is that I believe that the idea of interception proxies does not have sufficient technical merit to be published by IETF, and that IETF's publication of a document that tends to promote the use of such devices would actually be harmful to Internet operation and its ability to support applications. Reasonable people can disagree about the utility of an idea and I certainly don't expect that my notion of the utility of interception proxies will be accepted by everyone. (especially not folks who are making money by selling these things...) But I thought it was valuable to try to raise awareness about the issue. Keith p.s. I think the term you're looking for is "nihil obstat".
- Re: recommendation against... Keith Moore
- Re: recommendation against publica... Bill Sommerfeld
- Re: recommendation against pub... Patrik Fältström
- Re: recommendation against publication of d... Vernon Schryver
- Re: recommendation against publication... Valdis . Kletnieks
- Re: recommendation against publication of d... Vernon Schryver
- RE: recommendation against publication of d... Christian Huitema
- RE: recommendation against publication... Stephen Kent
- RE: recommendation against publication of d... Ian King
- Re: recommendation against publication of d... Peter Deutsch in Mountain View
- Re: recommendation against publication... Keith Moore
- Re: recommendation against publica... Peter Deutsch in Mountain View
- Re: recommendation against pub... Keith Moore
- Re: recommendation against... Peter Deutsch in Mountain View
- Re: recommendation ag... Theodore Y. Ts'o
- Re: recommendatio... Martin J.G. Williams
- Re: recommendation against publica... Valdis . Kletnieks
- Re: recommendation against pub... ned . freed
- Re: recommendation against... Dave Crocker
- Re: recommendation ag... ned . freed
- Re: recommendatio... Dave Crocker