I forgot to add the link #3 in my last email. So [3] https://www.dropbox.com/s/5j82arhhf0bif4h/ubosEdu_final.osm?dl=0
On 02/01/16 20:20, Rafael Avila Coya wrote: > Hi, Paul: > > Thanks for your comments: > > On 30/12/15 05:00, Paul Norman wrote: >> >> >> On 12/29/2015 4:15 PM, Rafael Avila Coya wrote: >>>>> The import has been communicated to the Uganda OSM community, and is >>>>> being submitted here for final validation by the wider OSM community. >>>> Can you provide a link to the Ugandan discussion? It's also wrong to >>>> refer to this as a final validation - it's discussion just like needed >>>> to be done with the Ugandan community, and neither is more a final >>>> validation than the other. >>> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ug/2015-December/000069.html >>> >>> >>> I just follow the imports guidelines. >> >> But my point is that this isn't a final validation, it's a consultation >> with the community, just as with talk-ug. >> >> Since talk-ug@ is a very quiet list, is there anywhere else the Ugandan >> community uses to talk? e.g. forums, a group elsewhere, FB, etc. With no >> response to the talk-ug@ message, it's hard to know if the locals want >> this or not. >> > A user from the Uganda community has shown up already. I guess more will > join. > > The Talk-ug is not that quiet. But imports is a complex enough matter to > draw less comments than usual. > > I'll do my best to involve the maximum people from the Uganda community > as possble. Jo's idea of trying to contact schools looks nice, although > quite complex to do. >> >>>> Looking at the suggested changeset comment, you should not mandate a >>>> particular comment, but have users use a good changeset comment[1]. >>> I agree completely. Thank you. I will add that to the workflow wiki. >> >> Don't forget the Import_Uganda_Bureau_Of_Statistics_Education_Facilities >> page too. > > True. That's corrected in both wikis. > >> >>>> You've also listed the source tag twice. >>> If you mean that source and source:date are both in the nodes and the >>> changeset, it's true. >> >> No, you're requiring people to use two source tags on the changeset, >> which is impossible. > > A small mistake. The second one was source:date. Corrected. > >> >>>> Past experience has shown that importing with a fixme doesn't work. They >>>> don't generally get fixed. >>> The fixme tag would affect an small subset of those 24,000+ nodes. >> >> How large a subset? Also, it doesn't really address what I raised. > > From a ramdom check of 100 nodes that I did, it would be kind of 10%. It > normally affects nurseries. > >> >>>> The workflow mentions abbreviations. Are these common enough to be worth >>>> expanding in the conversion script? >>> Yes. They are indeed very common. I will add the most complete set of >>> abbreviations to the final script so users will find as few as possible >>> of those abbreviations. Being 24,000+ nodes, it's really difficult to >>> correct all of them. >> >> What kind of portion will be left? > > The number of total nodes is 24,587 > > After abbreviating with the transformation script [1], there are only > 10,062 nodes unchanged. So that means it corrects the abbreviations of > 14,525 nodes the total set. > > With that new .osm, I opened it in JOSM, and checked 200 ramdom nodes of > the "new" 24,587. I got 20 of them (10% of the total) that needed to be > corrected their abbreviations. That means that around 2,459 nodes would > be left for the users to correct manually. The Tasking Manager project > will be divided in 607 tasks. That means an average of 40 nodes to be > imported per task. So every user would have to correct only 4 nodes per > task, average. > > The script corrects automatically 85.5% of the abbreviations, while the > users are left to correct the remaining 14.5% of all the nodes with > abbreviations (10% of the total nodes). > > You can check easily the abbreviations that the script corrects in this > txt file [2]. > > Hope this answer this question. > > To finish, in case you don't want to run the script, you can check the > final .osm file here [3] > > [1] https://www.dropbox.com/s/y343ye75p49rerp/transformUgandaEdu.awk?dl=0 > [2] > https://www.dropbox.com/s/ssbdk7dcru22sif/abbreviationsUgandaEdu.txt?dl=0 > [3] > > >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Imports mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports _______________________________________________ Imports mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
