First, thanks for opening the data and for starting an initiative to import all finnish bus stops into OSM.
Did you consider using osm_conflate / cf_audit for importing? It would greatly simplify an effort to conflate the data, and would provide a ready-made framework for adjusting bus stops position to imagery before the import is uploaded. Ilya > On 24 Oct 2018, at 14:58, Digiroad-info <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi everyone! > There have been several conversations in the Finnish OSM forums about > importing data from the Digiroad database to OSM. Digiroad is a national road > and street database administrated by the Finnish Transport Agency (FTA). > Inspired by the conversations we have created a bus stop import pilot > project. The purpose of the pilot is to complement OSM’s bus stop data with > data from Digiroad. > > Digiroad is the main database for public transport stop information in > Finland. According to a rough estimate, 60% of Finnish bus stop data is > missing from the OSM database. In this project, the missing data will be > provided to the OSM community for further development and application > purposes. > > In this import, OSM stops will be treated as master data. Thus, OSM stops > will not be removed or edited in anyway. To avoid overlapping data, the > Digiroad bus stop data will be filtered using common ID-numbers and locations > (for more info, please read our wiki!) > Data is planned to be imported in two phases. In the piloting phase, we plan > to test all the processes with a small test set data. The test set will be > imported during October or November 2018 and the exact time of the import > depends on the OSM community’s feedback. > After the import, the Digiroad operator organizes a mapathon event 5th of > November at the GIS Expo in Helsinki together with the local OSM community. > The aim of the mapathon is to move the Digiroad stops from the original > center line geometry location to the actual bus stop shelter or pole > location, and more tags can also be added in process. > In the second phase, the Digiroad bus stop data gathered from the rest of > Finland will be imported after successful and well-received import of the > test data. Similar mapathons than in GIS-expo will be organized also after > the main import. > This import has been planned in the Finnish Transport Agency's (FTA) Digiroad > operating service and together with Mr. Erno Mäkinen (Gispo Oy), who has been > the consultant for the project regarding preliminary OSM community opinion. > Data license is OK. OSM-community has a written permission from the FTA to > import the data. > Wiki page for the project: http://bit.ly/DR_OSMwiki <http://bit.ly/DR_OSMwiki> > > More about the Digiroad: > https://www.liikennevirasto.fi/web/en/open-data/digiroad#.W9BddOllLXE > <https://www.liikennevirasto.fi/web/en/open-data/digiroad#.W9BddOllLXE> > > With best regards, > Meri > Digiroad-operaattori > [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> > 040 507 2301 (klo 9-16) > www.digiroad.fi <http://www.digiroad.fi/> > > Digiroad Twitterissä <https://twitter.com/Digiroad_fi> > Liity Digiroadin Slack-keskustelukanavalle > <https://confirmsubscription.com/h/i/27D81F626C183731> > Tilaa Digiroad-hyödyntäjien uutiskirje > <https://confirmsubscription.com/h/i/F3B0C96DB2C57204> > > _______________________________________________ > Imports mailing list > [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports > <https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports>
_______________________________________________ Imports mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
