Hi, Łukasz:
I don't know what happens with the [5] link. But it opens without
problem to me. Maybe you can try through the arquived mail here:
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/imports/2020-August/006353.html
Cheers,
Rafael.
O 29/08/20 ás 19:53, Łukasz Taraszka escribiu:
Hello Rafael,
Thanks for your response.
I know the standards described on mentioned wiki pages.
The opinion of companies, as well as the opinion of anyone else
(individuals, organizations, etc.), is always welcome in OpenStreetMap,
but we should not adjust our tagging schema to the needs of different
companies, because they aren't the only ones interested in using the
data. We map the reality the best we can, but we can't map for the
different data consumers, because they will have in general different
needs that we can't accommodate.
And
According to you, they say "if there will be a standard accepted by the
OSM community they would do this and that". But there is actually a
standard accepted by the community, that is what you read in the already
mentioned Public transport and other wikis. With lots of discussions,
and new proposals, yes, but we have and we follow those wikis to map
public transport everywhere around the world, and quite well in my
honest opinion.
I totally agree with that. I proposed two new tags and I'm not going to
change existing standards.
I proposed stop_id and stop_no as placeholders which could be replaced
with something that is more relevant to this situation.
Probably gtfs_id and local_ref as was suggested on Polish forum.
My goal is to find a middle ground between OSM community standards and
the companies which are delivering systems for blinds for years.
Both sides have their standards.
Apart from the tagging mailing list, I would suggest you first to
contact your local Polish osm community, for example through the talk-pl
mailing list [6]. I am sure they will be very glad to discuss with you
about mapping all those objects for Katowice and other areas, so
valuable for disabled people.
It's already there.
For example, in one of the
tram stops examples of yours [5], we would have the following tags:
I wasn't able to check that because link [5] is pointing to an incorrect
location. Could you please send me the correct example?
--
Best regards,
Taraszka Łukasz
czw., 27 sie 2020 o 17:01 Mateusz Konieczny via Imports
<[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> napisał(a):
27 Aug 2020, 16:38 by [email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>:
Apart from the tagging mailing list, I would suggest you first
to contact your local Polish osm community, for example through
the talk-pl mailing list [6]. I am sure they will be very glad
to discuss with you about mapping all those objects for Katowice
and other areas, so valuable for disabled people.
There was already contact (through
OSM forum, Polish community is not
using mailing list), and this reminds me that
I should reply also there
_______________________________________________
Imports mailing list
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
--
Pozdrawiam
Taraszka Łukasz
tel. 668 462 791
_______________________________________________
Imports mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
