Thank you very much Pankaj ji for pictures and information on A papilosa. I have taken note of the differences mentioned by you. I think, I would go to the location and take another clear picture from all possible angles and record observations in the field notes.
Just for loud laugh, Matherana rajeshii was name given to me by Smita madam (my orchid guru) and Giby ji even defined the taxonomic meaning of it and the other day you also commented on that too but nothing on serious note. But I liked this "so called phirangi name" :) I dont know when they changed my gender ;) On Fri, Nov 16, 2012 at 4:58 AM, Dr Pankaj Kumar <[email protected]>wrote: > That someone who created the confusion was me only !!! > Its very strange, but I saw all those pics by Pradnyavant but some times > pics dont help to 100% accuracy. > One fine day during my PhD work I was driving through forests of Saranda > in Jharkhand and I saw huge plants. I was surprised, because, its like I > have pics and shadows of orchids, that I have seen, in my head. Its hard to > explain how!!! and whenever those which I see in front of my eyes dont > match with the shadows in my head, I can make out that they are different > without even knowing the whole plant. The plant I saw that day was too big > for anything to fit in from Jharkhand, My driver who was actually sitting > next to me (I was driving), I stopped the car, went on back gear to around > 300m and then stopped, got out of car and I knew the big orchid though it > was new record for Jharkhand. My driver said WOW WO ORCHID KYA HAI???? but > I knew what it was and I said, WOW TO MUJHE PATA HAI, BUT USKE BAGAL ME > CHHOTA WALA KYA HAI? And I walked to this plant, which actually had fruits > smaller than my imagination. I said, WOW YE TO ACAMPE PRAEMORSA KA BACHHA > LAGTA HAI and we started laughing. I was 100% sure it was Acampe but not > praemorsa. Later I identified it as Acampe papillosa, second new record for > Jharkhand. On this day, I found 4 new records for Jharkhand!!! > Having seen both plants in real I know they are different, before that me > too thought them to be same. Fruit is papillosa is around 2-3 cm long but > in praemorsa its more than 5cm and 10 times thicker than papillosa. Leaves > can some times be double the size in praemorsa. Roots are thicker in > praemorsa and ofcourse the spur is more pronounced in papillosa. Apart from > usual smaller size of flowers (though not much). > > Hope you can make out the different between these two plants > > > <https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-fOL55GOMqqA/UKV5ObFSMuI/AAAAAAAABYs/iJ5ePXh7lhc/s1600/Slide18.JPG> > > > > <https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-YQS9a3A6OfQ/UKV5yl0Sl1I/AAAAAAAABY0/hSj5iNml41Y/s1600/Slide16.JPG> > > > > On Friday, 16 November 2012 01:35:05 UTC+8, matherana.rajeshii wrote: >> >> Dear efI members, >> A posting made by one of orchid enthusiastic Mr Pradnyavant Mane, on the >> facebook group called "Orchids of the Western Ghats' has brought a lot of >> discussion and great confusion for us. Some observers, on personal note, >> said that Acampe praemorsa and A papilosa are synonym. Wherein others >> believe that both are different species and have different flowering >> season. I am posting both clicks on efI and look forward for some more >> light on it. I have attached Acampe praemorsa that was clicked by me on the >> south part of Sanjay Gandhi National Park , clicked on 18th May`12 and >> another Acampe , clicked by Mr Mane on 9th Nov`12 on northern part of >> Sanjay Gandhi National Park. >> >> -- >> Regards >> Rajesh Sachdev >> https://www.facebook.com/**matherana.rajeshii<https://www.facebook.com/matherana.rajeshii> >> https://www.facebook.com/**groups/indianflora/<https://www.facebook.com/groups/indianflora/> >> >> -- > > > > -- Regards Rajesh Sachdev https://www.facebook.com/matherana.rajeshii https://www.facebook.com/groups/indianflora/ --
