http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/02/23/transnational-movement-destroy-shia-indonesia-scholar.html


Transnational movement to destroy Shia in Indonesia: Scholar
Bambang Muryanto, The Jakarta Post, Yogyakarta | Archipelago | Sat, February 23 
2013, 9:57 AM 

Paper Edition | Page: 5

A transnational movement has entered Indonesia to destroy the Shia sect, which 
has existed in Aceh since the fourth century, a scholar has said.

Azyumardi Azra of Syarif Hidayatulah State Islamic University (UIN) in Jakarta 
said that after the success of the 1979 Iran revolution and the emergence of 
Saudi Arabia as a petro-dollar country, a movement had begun to fund the 
anti-Shia Wahhabi movement.

“The Wahhabi movement in Indonesia runs independently and enters different 
groups,” Azyumardi said after giving a keynote speech at an international 
conference on Shia held in Yogyakarta earlier this week

One of the groups that has been aggressively against Shia, according to him, is 
the Salafi group, an off-shoot of Jafar Umar Thalib’s Laskar Jihad. “The Salafi 
group has networks in Saudi Arabia,” Azyumardi said.

He called on the government to be firm with both groups in regards to violence. 
“The law has to be reinforced. There is no impunity for groups committing 
violence,” Azyumardi said.

On the recent conflicts between Shia and Sunni in Sampang, Madura, Azyumardi 
said the case did not involve religious matters. The case was triggered by 
political and economic interests, and it grew bigger and uncontrolled because 
the security authorities had failed to act firmly against the group that had 
committed violence.

Shia and Sunni Muslims, according to Azyumardi, actually share many common 
beliefs. 

The Iran Ambassador to Indonesia, Mahmoud Farazandeh, who also attended the 
conference, said that Shia and Sunni in Indonesia had culturally united and 
peacefully co-existed for thousands of years. “They are inseparable,” he said.

Another speaker at the forum, Siti Maryam of Kalijaga UIN in Yogyakarta, said 
that traces of Shia in Java could be easily found. 

Among other examples is the tradition of cooking porridge during the month of 
Sura, according to the Javanese calendar and the symbol of the Cirebon Kingdom 
that uses the image of the sword of Sayyidina Ali (bin Abi Thalib).

“In Java, Sunni and Shia acculturation occurs mostly in areas far from the 
reach of the ‘control’ of the religious authority such as in the domain of art 
and culture,” Siti said.

Observations conducted by Agus Sunyoto of Brawijaya University in Malang, East 
Java, strengthened Siti’s view. Agus said the kenduri (thanksgiving) tradition 
had come from Iran. The tradition of commemorating the 40th day of the death of 
a loved one was influenced by Shia and not by Hinduism, as widely believed.

Other examples include the tradition among Javanese people to not hold wedding 
parties during the month of Sura, which was also the same month of the death of 
Sayyidina Ali. Javanese believe that having parties during Sura would bring 
them bad luck.

“Islam in Indonesia cannot be seen as black and white, between Shia or Sunni, 
as both have influenced each other,” said Agus who claimed to have conducted 
extensive research on Shia.

Separately, Siti Samsiatun of the Indonesia Consortium for Religious Studies 
(ICRS), which organized the conference expressed hope that the forum would 
inspire mutual understanding between Shia and Sunni Muslims in Southeast Asia. 
Shia, which is also present in Thailand, Malaysia and Singapore, has been 
banned in Malaysia.

“There has been misunderstandings due to the lack of communication. This 
conference will hopefully help bring peace among the people,” Siti said.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke