http://investorline.co.in/

Inheritance: Women prefer peace with brothers
 Surekha Pandit was adamant. The 35-year-old found herself cajoling and
arguing with her husband and in-laws all the time. The subject? The division
of the family property and other assets. Ironically, however, the struggle
wasn't for herself. "On principle, I wanted an equal share for my husband's
divorced sister who had returned home. Even if that meant that her share
would eat into my husband's," says the Mumbai-based lawyer. She finally had
her way and her sister-in-law was taken care of.

Despite clear provisions in succession laws, a fair share for the daughter,
in reality, is still a sporadic sighting. Pandit's family is one such. In
another uncommon case, a divorced daughter in Mumbai was given not only
ownership, but control in the family's business.

Yet, there is a definite whiff of change in the few homes that possess an
open and a more progressive outlook. They are slowly coming around to
accepting equitable distribution of wealth as the decent way of life.

Says certified financial planner Kartik Jhaveri, "The law provides for a
well-defined succession plan. More often than not, we see it being agreed
to, especially where ancestral property is concerned." In non-ancestral
property, the person has the discretion of distribution and may want to
alter the share. "It is a funny situation . Normally we don't see an
unmarried woman come in for planning. Entire families do."

Mutual funds -  http://mutualfunds.investorline.co.in/
Life Insurance -   http://insurance.investorline.co.in/
The bulk of daughters in our country have been structured to accept their
wedding gifts or streedhan, scoot to their newfound family and never look
back for more. Mumbai's Sita Venkatraman, 30, remembers the time her mother
sold their flat, which was in her deceased father's name. Her brothers were
given an equal share of the amount. "I and my sister, who were married by
then, were gifted a silk saree each," she says, with an understanding smile.
Zankhana Shah, of MoneyCare Financial Planning, says in her experience, she
has seen women mostly get "up to" 10% of the total wealth.

And, as we all know, only in extreme adversity does a married daughter's
original family chip in funds to see her through. Senior Mumbai psychiatrist
Dr Ashit Sheth remembers a distressed woman whose brother remained
indifferent to her crumbling marriage and financial condition. "Even if
women want to do something, the command of the business lies with their
brothers, who do not want to entertain any 'dependency' ." Clearly, they
must find the thought of sharing the spoils with sisters heartwrenching.

That the sister does not pursue her rights strongly enough to maintain
family peace adds another complexity to the issue. As advocate and women's
rights activist Flavia Agnes says, "My experience is that women are not
bothered." They may make a claim on their husband's wealth, says Agnes, but
not their father's.


This brings us to another bigger problem — even in this day and age, most
women don't even know about their rights and that the law provides for them.
Planner like Kartik Jhaveri strongly advise women to take an active interest
in the financial goings-on of their homes. "Ninety eight per cent women
don't know what's happening. Money comes in it and gets deployed wherever;
signatures are taken..."

Mutual funds -  http://mutualfunds.investorline.co.in/
Life Insurance -   http://insurance.investorline.co.in/
Even if they are aware about the laws and wish to stake their claim, they
remain clueless about how to go about it. Senior Kolkata advocate Gitanath
Ganguly, executive chairman, legal aid services of West Bengal, says: "The
problem is, women don't know where to go and how to go about getting their
due. Therefore, what is needed are more legal literacy programmes by the
government." Ganguly renders some practical advice: "The first thing you
must do, instead of going to the court or hiring lawyer, is approach the
nearest legal aid centre, which offers counselling and assistance." But why
wait for such an eventuality?

Lawyers recommend women mustensure their names are secured in the nomination
papers of propertyand bank accounts of their parents. Also, however
uncomfortable the thought, women must insist on a paternal or maternal will.
Lawyers and financial planners suggest parents must put together a will till
they "are still in their senses" to safeguard a daughter's interests. An
equitable division must ideally be made before her marriage. Mumbai advocate
Shobha Jagtiani says a valid will doesn't require a lawyer's presence. A
short will with a clear date, even if prepared without a detailed list, is
legitimate, if it is signed by two witnesses. A copy of the same could then
be kept with a lawyer. A more focused and transparent approach to
will-making , especially in families with large assets to share, would be to
involve a third-party facilitator. Shah speaks of a division of assets among
two brothers and a sister.

The family, which runs a finance company, sat down to split its wealth of a
couple of crores. The daughter was offered a directorship in the company,
some shareholding, a few offices and cash. "Succession plan is not 'by the
way' ," says Shah. Here, the planner prepares an objective listing of
behavioural attitudes of each family member. In a family, one son may
believe in lifestyle, one just pure fun and the daughter in adventure. Each
of them would thus have a unique approach towards money. "Like, if one
doesn't like philanthropy, he can't be given a trust to manage." Division of
wealth is thus conducted after "navigating family dynamics" . Splitting an
inheritance , also termed "sudden money" , is certainly not an easy job. "It
brings along its opportunities and challenges for allocation." Allocation
also depends on each individual's short and long-term goals. Now, how much
do your daughter's goals matter?


Visit our site at – http://newsroom.investorline.co.in/
Learning Center-  http://learning.investorline.co.in/
Mutual funds -  http://mutualfunds.investorline.co.in/
Life Insurance -   http://insurance.investorline.co.in/
Investor Journal -  http://research.investorline.co.in/
Latest News - http://investorline.co.in/blogger/?q=aggregator/categories/1
News Resources - http://investorline.co.in/blogger/?q=aggregator/sources
Newscatcher- http://catcher.investorline.co.in/

Newsgroups- http://groups.google.com/group/india-investor

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Get latest market updates & search internet right from your browser-download 
our toolbar here- http://investorline.ourtoolbar.com/ 

Visit our site at – http://investorline.co.in/
Newsroom: http://newsroom.investorline.co.in/
Learning Center-  http://learning.investorline.co.in/
Mutual funds -  http://mutualfunds.investorline.co.in/ 
Life Insurance -   http://insurance.investorline.co.in/
Investor Journal -  http://research.investorline.co.in/
Newscatcher- http://catcher.investorline.co.in/

Interested in Financial Planning-Let us Contact you- 
http://spreadsheets.google.com/viewform?key=pb_z4f1_zGMg4iBBFT3-SWQ&email=true 

If you like the site then promote it here- 
https://www.freetellafriend.com/tell/?url=http://investorline.co.in/blogs/news 
Create your own free blog on- http://investorline.co.in/blogger 

Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/india-investor
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to