In some email I received from Paul B. Henson, sie wrote: > > On Mon, 29 Apr 2002, Crist J. Clark wrote: > > > I take what I said before back. There _is_ an obvious reason why it > > won't (shouldn't, still haven't tested) work. Bridged packets would > > only go through ipnat(1) on input. They'd only get NAT'ed in one > > direction which, obviously, won't work. > > > > I knew this (and didn't care since a NAT'ing bridge is such a heinous > > concept (oh, and it would be a lot more work to do it right)) back > > when I was adding the code, but then I forgot it in the meantime. > > I am currently setting up a transparent bridge firewall, and was interested > in trying out the ftp proxy. As I understand, that works via the NAT > engine. Intuitively, it seems like it should be able to work on a bridge as > there is no actual manipulation of IP addresses or ports, just monitoring > the stream and opening up a dynamic hole for the return connection. > > But it sounds like you're saying that the FTP proxy won't work on a bridge? > Bummer :(...
Well, you don't know until you try. Darren
