Hey,

I discovered that the bridge wasn't filtering anymore when  by accident
one day when I tried to SSH in to my network
from the outside and succeeded. I then tried all my boxes and succeeded on
those too.It was pretty scary.

I did read somewhere in a newsgroup that there was a problem with OpenBSD
bridges and filtering on packets going out. That's supposed to be resolved
with the latest 3.1 version. What version are you running?

STP stands for Spanning Tree Protocal. I've got two OpenBSD bridges with
the same rulesets plugged into the same switch. If you've got STP enabled
on both boxes this will regulate which machine is the master or slave. If
the master fails the slave will take over. In my case, the master machine
didn't fail i.e. the interface was still up and the stp was still working,
so it just stayed master and whilst letting all traffic pass.

I think I need to upgrade to the latest OpenBSD and use PF.

Laters,

Herman


On Thu, 31 Oct 2002 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

>
> You never seem to get good response on this list to bridge questions.  --I never 
>have anyway.  I don't think many people are using it as a bridge and it isn't 
>documented very well either.  I am using it to protect about 900 workstations and 100 
>servers with a 140 line ruleset.  I have never seen it stop firewalling but we have 
>had a lot of troubles with the state table filling up.  Finally we setup a machine 
>with a state table in the 90k states neighborhood and since then haven't seen much 
>trouble.  Granted since I have never noticed it not firewalling I have never checked 
>much for it either.  I just assume it works.  How did you discover this?
>
> One thing we do have troubles with -- just this morning in fact, is workstations are 
>not able to web browse out.  It happens every so often.  ipfstat doesn't show 
>anything out of the ordinary.
>
> What is STP?  Currently I have the firewall email me the ruleset every midnight and 
>I try to keep it up to date every so often on a backup machine that is running but 
>the bridge net cards are not plugged into the net.
>
> When the firewalling stops, what do the ipfstat numbers look like?
>
> --ja
>
> On Thu, 31 Oct 2002, Sonja Appelman wrote:
>
> > Hi,
> >
> > I've been running an OpenBSD 2.9 firewalling bridge using IPF for more
> > than a year very successfully. I've been most pleased. But just recently out of
> > the blue, the bridge started letting ALL traffic through! I immediately
> > rebooted the machine and everything went back to normal, i.e. it started
> > blocking again. But after a few days the same occured, it started letting
> > all traffic through. Needless to say I've switched the machine off for
> > now.
> >
> > It was running in unison with another OpenBSD 2.9 firewalling bridge, same
> > hardware specs, same ipf rules, etc. I've been using STP to keep the
> > Master/Slave relationship in check. Each machine has 3 interface cards. 2
> > for the bridging and the third interface for simply copying the ipf
> > ruleset from the master to the slave via a cross-over cable.
> >
> > Does anyone out there have any clue as to what went wrong?
> >
> > Thanks for any help you can give.
> >
> > Herman
> > :)
> >
> >
> >
>
> --
>
>
>

Reply via email to