After reading the Hinden/Haberman ID, I do not understand how does it (if it does) 
simplify the routing mechanism as described in the “impact of Site-Local addressing” 
ID, as described in 3.1.2.2:

“First, the forwarding engine on an SBR must look at both the source and destination 
addresses to determine if either of them is link- local.  If so, the packet will be 
discarded, as above.  

If the destination is not link-local, it must be either site-local or global. If the 
destination address is site-local, the router will look at the interface on which the 
packet was received to determine the site-local zone in which the packet originated, 
and will perform a lookup in the correct site-local forwarding table and forward the 
packet, as indicated. 

If the destination address is global, the router will perform a lookup in the global 
routing table.  It will then use the inbound interface to determine the site-local 
zone in which the packet originated, and the outbound interface to determine the 
site-local zone in which the packet will be sent.  If those zones do not match, then 
the packet is being forwarded across a site boundary. In that case, the router will 
need to re-examine the source address of the packet to determine if the source is 
site-local.  If so, the packet will be discarded, and an ICMP "scope exceeded" error 
message will be generated. Otherwise, the packet will be forwarded, as indicated. 

This processing will need to be performed for every packet that is forwarded by an 
SBR, and this level of complexity will impact the Impact of Site-Local Addressing in 
performance, cost and reliability of all IPv6 routers with SBR capability.”


Aviad Raveh

Radlan Computer Communications Ltd.
Atidim Technological Park Bldg #4
Tel Aviv 61131 Israel
Tel:      +972-3-7658909


--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPng Working Group Mailing List
IPng Home Page:                      http://playground.sun.com/ipng
FTP archive:                      ftp://playground.sun.com/pub/ipng
Direct all administrative requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to