At 06:49 AM 30/06/2004, Brian Haberman wrote:
All,
     As a part of the IESG review, a member of the RIR community has
provided comments on the ULA draft.  I will posting those comments to
the mailing list as separate notes shortly.  As a part of that review,
Bob & I made the decision to split the ULA draft into two drafts.  One
draft discusses only the locally allocated addresses.  The second draft
discusses the centrally-allocated addresses.


Hi Brian,

As this is a working group document I would like to understand on what basis this decision was taken. I could be mistaken here but I would've thought that it would be reasonable for the working group chairs to seek the views of the working group before making changes to a working group document. The basis for my concern here is that I see this splitting of the document into two as an action that appears to take a fundamental problem of assured address uniqueness and turns it into what could be loosely characterized as a random free-for-all. I'm personally unconvinced that what appears from the outside to be short term expediency on the part of the WG Chairs should be an acceptable substitute for, at the very least, seeking the views of the working group prior to making such decisions.

regards,

  Geoff Huston






-------------------------------------------------------------------- IETF IPv6 working group mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6 --------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to