JEMAAH MUHAMMAD SAW-WHICH ONE IS THE TRUE JEMAAH MUHAMMAD SAW?
May 30, 2012 by mthago
http://mthago.wordpress.com/2012/05/30/jemaah-muhammad-saw-which-one-is-the-true-jemaah-muhammad-saw/

We have to be with Jemaah Muhammad saw and only with this jemaah we will 
achieve salvation. In order to attain the love of Allah, we have to be part of 
the Jemaah Muhammad saw. Nowadays there are many jemaah or groups of Muslims in 
this world. All of them claim to belong to Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw. 
Prophet Muhammad saw said with approximate meaning "my umat will be divided 
into 73 jemaah (or groups) but only one group or jemaah is following the true 
path. When the companions of Prophet Muhammad saw asked Prophet Muhammad saw 
which group or jemaah is following the true path? Prophet Muhammad saw answered 
with the approximate meaning, the jemaah or group that follows me and my 
companions". Whoever follows the companions of Prophet Muhammad saw will also 
follows Prophet Muhammad saw and so the jemaah or group which follows the true 
path is the jemaah or group that follows Muhammad saw and his companions. Crowd 
of peoples will not make a jemaah or a group unless there is a leader or 
`Amer'. The Amer of Jemaah Muhammad saw and his companions is Prophet Muhammad 
saw himself and after the demise of Prophet Muhammad saw the Amer of Jemaah 
Muhammad saw and his companions should be the disciples of Prophet Muhammad saw 
or the `Naib' of Prophet Muhammad saw. Naib or disciples of Prophet Muhammad is 
not a Prophet but has the same mission, vision and work like Prophet Muhammad 
saw. What is the work of Prophet Muhammad saw? The work of Prophet Muhammad saw 
is to call people towards Allah with full conviction, determination and 
perseverance.

When there is not even one person from among the umat of Prophet Muhammad saw 
who has the same vision, mission and work as Prophet Muhammad saw, there will 
be no one who is capable of becoming the Naib or disciple of Prophet Muhammad 
saw. When there is no one who is capable of becoming the Amer of the Jemaah 
Muhammad saw, there will be no jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw in this world. In 
other words in this world there will be no jemaah which is following the 
correct path. When leaders are wrong, all those who follow the leaders are also 
wrong. Without even a single person who is following the path or Tarikat of 
Prophet Muhammad saw, there will be no jemaah or group in this world which is 
following the correct path. Many believe that at all time there must be at 
least one group or jemaah from among the umat of Prophet Muhammad saw which is 
following the correct path. This is not true. When none from among the umat of 
Prophet Muhammad saw is striving towards the correct path, Allah will not guide 
anyone from among the umat of Prophet Muhammad saw towards the correct path. 
Guidance or hidayah is not a matter of coincidence. Allah ordered us to work on 
gaining guidance or hidayah. Allah will give hidayah or guidance only to those 
who strive towards hidayah. When all of the umat of Prophet Muhammad saw is in 
love with the worldly thing, their heart will be devoid of the love of Islam. 
When their hearts are devoid of the love of Islam, none will ever do the work 
of enjoining peoples to Good and forbidding peoples from Evils (amar makruf 
nahi mungkar). When this happen, it means none of them is fulfilling the right 
of the Great Kalimah (the first pillar of 5 Rukun Islam) and Allah will not 
make the Great Kalimah enter into their hearts. When the Great Kalimah is not 
entering their heart, their actions are devoid of sincerity, Allah will not 
give them the understanding of the Quran and Allah will make them deviated from 
the true path.

Many from among the jemaah or groups claim that they are also doing the work of 
enjoining peoples to Good and forbidding peoples from Evils. However the way 
they are doing the work of enjoining good and forbidding evils is entirely 
different from the way done by Prophet Muhammad saw. Generally many Muslims 
believe evils are the wrong doings or injustices done by non-Muslims towards 
Muslims. Many Muslims believe the evils done by non-Muslims need to be 
prevented by organizing street demonstration, asking Muslims not to buy 
products produce by the countries that do injustices to Muslims or declaring 
wars on the non-Muslims and their countries. They do not regard the greatest 
evil of the non-Muslims is they do not want to recite the Great Kalimah and to 
prevent the evil is to invite the non-Muslims to recite the Great Kalimah. Many 
Muslims think when a non-Muslims do injustice to a Muslims, the non-Muslim is 
the enemy of Islam and Muslims. Many groups or jemaah of Muslims regard 
Americans and the Jews as the enemies of Muslims and Islam. They believe the 
Americans and the Jews are the enemies of Muslims and Islam and to kill them is 
an act of Jihad and to die in doing so is an act of a matyrs. They regard 
themselves as Mujahidin and they look down towards other Muslims who are not in 
the same struggle as them and they call other Muslims as coward. They interpret 
the Hadis that say we must prevent evils even with our heart is to hate the 
evil doers. Since Jews and Americans are evil doers, Muslims must hate them and 
pray for their destruction. Even this groups or jemaah believe they are the 
jemaah or group whom Prophet Muhammad saw mentioned in the Hadis as the only 
one that follows the correct path. Among the most notable jemaah or groups 
belong to this are the Al-Qaeda, Jemaah Muslimin, Buku Haram (in Nigeria) and 
many others. There are many Muslims groups or jemaah in the world but all of 
them claim that they are following the correct path and that they follow 
Prophet Muhammad saw by enjoining peoples to Good and forbidding peoples from 
Evils.

When Jews do certain act of injustice towards the Palestinians, many Muslims 
call the act as an act of evils. When the Americans burn the Qur'an in 
Afghanistan, many Muslims call the act as an act of evil. When there is an act 
of evil, according to Hadis, Muslims must stop the evils, either by using 
force, or by words or by having hatred towards the evil acts in their heart. 
Many Muslims who are more extreme in their believe like the members of 
Al-Qaeda, Jemaah Muslimin, Buku Haram and many others want to use act of force 
to stop the evils done by the Americans and the Jews. What they understand by 
using act of force to stop evil is by killing the Jews and the Americans or to 
destroy places of importance to the Jews and the Americans. Other Muslims who 
are not ready to use force to stop evils will use their mouth to stop the 
evils. What they understand by using their mouth to stop evils is by doing 
street demonstrations and screaming bad words in the street or displaying 
banners written with bad words towards the Jews and Americans. Other Muslims 
who are not ready to use their mouth to stop evils will use their heart to stop 
the evils. What they understand by using their heart to stop evils is to hate 
the evil doers and in this particular case is to hate both the Jews and the 
Americans in their heart. Instead of inviting the Jews and the Americans to 
recite the Great Kalimah with love and affection, and if they do not want to 
embrace Islam, Muslims should pray for the Jews and Americans to embrace Islam, 
Muslims are told by their Muslims scholars to hate the Jews and the Americans. 
This is not the teaching of Islam but yet due to the inability of Muslims 
scholars to understand the Quran and Hadis correctly, hatred towards the Jews 
and the Americans has become virtues to some Muslims.

When Muslims are told by their Muslims scholars to hate Jews and the Americans, 
many Muslims follows blindly the advice of their scholars and will use whatever 
it takes to hate or to kill the Jews and the Americans. Muslims with this wrong 
understanding of Quran and Hadis are the Muslims who bomb the Casino in Bali 
and many others in the world. Although their actions are not in accordance with 
Quran and Hadis yet they regard themselves as good Muslims and they claim they 
are following the jemaah or group of Prophet Muhammad saw. They also believe, 
in case they die on this path they will die as martyrs and they will enter 
paradise. Many Muslims do not understand the meaning of the Hadis of Prophet 
Muhammad saw that say; If you witness an evil act, you must stop it using your 
hand (power). If you cannot stop the evil act with your hand, you must used 
your mouth (words) and if you cannot stop the evil act with your mouth, you 
must stop the evil act with your heart (prayers or make doa). Many Muslims 
interpret and understand the words, using your hand to stop the evil acts as 
using power to stop the evil acts. Many Muslims understand the word of using 
power as using force. Many Muslims understand the words of using force as using 
machines guns, bomb and other ammunition to kill the evil doers and in this 
particular case the evil doers are the Jews and the Americans.

It is sad to say that many Muslims including their scholars do not understand 
the true meaning of the Quran and the Hadis. Because of their wrong 
interpretation of Quran and Hadis, Muslims are known in the world as 
terrorists. None can give Muslims the understanding of the Quran and Hadis 
except Allah. Why Allah does not give the Muslims the understanding of the 
Quran and the Hadis? Although many Muslims can read and memorize the Quran and 
Hadis but Allah does not give them the understanding of the Quran and Hadis. 
Allah does not give the understanding of the Quran and Hadis to the Muslims and 
to their scholars because Muslims are not inviting peoples to good and 
preventing peoples from evils in the way shown by our Prophet Muhammad saw 
.Many Muslims including their scholars do not understand the word good and 
evils mention in the Quran and Hadis. Many Muslims including their scholars do 
not know that the order to invite peoples to good and preventing peoples from 
evils is actually the fulfillment of the right of the first order of Allah 
which is to recite the Great Kalimah, I bear witness there is no God except 
Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah. Many Muslims 
including their scholars do not know that the evil mention in the Quran and 
Hadis; it means not to recognize Allah as the only God and Muhammad as the 
messenger of Allah or not to recite the Great Kalimah. Many Muslims including 
their scholars do not know the good mention in the Quran and Hadis; it means to 
recite the Great Kalimah.

All other evils done by men can only be prevented when the greatest evil done 
by men is prevented by Muslims. There is no point to prevent other evils when 
the great evil is not prevented. How Muslims prevent the greatest evil done by 
men? The greatest evil done by men can be prevented by Muslims by Muslims 
inviting men to do the greatest good. What is the greatest Good done by men? 
The greatest good done by men is to recite the Great Kalimah; I bear witness 
there is no God except Allah and I bear witness Muhammad is the messenger of 
Allah. Muslims have to invite men to do the greatest good without using any 
force. Muslims must invite men to do the greatest good, the way Prophet 
Muhammad saw did. Allah wants men to recite the Great Kalimah without force or 
compulsion. Muslims have to invite men to recite the Great Kalimah with love, 
affection and kindness. Muslims are not allowed to use any force in inviting 
men to recite the Great Kalimah. Allah wants men to recite the Great Kalimah 
with willingness. Allah does not accept the recitation of the Great Kalimah 
done without willingness. Allah has given the choice to men either to recite or 
not to recite the Great Kalimah. Muslims are ordered only to invite them to 
recite the Great Kalimah but not to force them to recite the Great Kalimah. 
Muslims are not to wage war on anybody who refuses to recite the Great Kalimah. 
Muslims are not to obtain any material gain from those who refuse to recite the 
Great Kalimah. Muslims have to invite men to recite the Great Kalimah in the 
way of Prophet Muhammad saw.

Our intention to invite men to recite the Great Kalimah is only to please Allah 
and not to gain popularity or any materials gain. Muslims are not allowed to 
force peoples to accept the Great Kalimah. Muslim will only wage war on those 
who wage war on the Muslims. Allah has not ordered Muslims to start any war 
with anybody and at anytime. Muslims will only wage wars on those who wages war 
on the Muslims. War becomes an order of Allah when Muslims are attack by their 
enemies. War is only allowed in order to defend Muslims against the attack of 
their enemies. Allah ordered Muslims to prevent evil with their hand does not 
means to use force to invite men to recite the Great Kalimah .What it means is; 
when a Muslim is given power by Allah, he or she must used the power to call 
peoples to Allah with love and affection but not to use the power to amass 
wealth or land. When a Muslim is given power by Allah; for example he or she is 
the Prime Minister of a country, and as a Prime Minister he or she has the 
power to use the national media such as newspaper, radio and television of the 
country to call the peoples to Allah with love and affection. As a Prime 
Minister, he or she will have the power to visit and gather peoples in large 
numbers in many places in the country and to use the opportunities to call 
peoples to Allah with love and affection. Although the Prime Minister has power 
yet the method of calling peoples to Allah, remain the method of inviting with 
love and kindness, without the use of any force of any kinds.

However, the Companions (Sahabah) of Prophet Muhammad saw use method which is 
suitable to their time. Sahabah initially will invite the King to recite the 
Great Kalimah. In case the King refuses to recite the Great Kalimah, Sahabah 
will ask the King to pay money known as jizyah to the Muslims and in case the 
King refuses to pay jizyah, Sahabah will declare war against the King and the 
armies of the King. Muslims will give the King three days to decide whether to 
accept Islam, or to pay jizyah or to fight with the Muslims. Although the 
method used by the companions was suitable to their time but the method used by 
the Prophet Muhammad saw is suitable at all time. Many Muslims do not 
understand the Quran and Hadis and as a result many Jemaah or groups 
established by Muslims are not the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw and yet they 
claimed they are the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw. In one Hadis the Prophet 
Muhammad saw advice Muslims not to run away from a Jemaah and if they do, they 
will die like peoples of Jahiliah or as an infidel. What it means by the Jemaah 
in this Hadis is the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw and not any other Jemaah or 
groups. It is a commendable act to run away from the Jemaah or groups that do 
not belong to the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw. As for example, Muslims from 
Jemaah Tabligh think they belong to the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw but in 
reality they are not. Because they think they are on the correct path, they 
told me not to leave Jemaah Tabligh, otherwise I will die as peoples of 
Jahiliah or as an infidel. Members of Jemaah Tabligh think and believe they 
belong to the Jemaah of Prophet Muhammad saw but all their actions are against 
the practices of Muhammad saw .One very important guideline or tertib in Jemaah 
Tabligh which is against the practice of Prophet Muhammad saw is they do not 
encourage their members to invite the non-Muslims to embrace Islam with the 
reason they say; Muslims need to be rectified first before Muslims can invite 
the non-Muslims to recite the Great Kalimah. What a shame on Jemaah Tabligh!

Prof. Dr. Nasoha Saabin
May 2012
Dean of Faculty of Optometry
International University College of Technology Twintech
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia



------------------------------------

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JIMedia: Memurnikan Tanggapan Umum Melalui Penyebaran Ilmu dan Maklumat

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Nota: Kandungan mel ini tidak menggambarkan pendirian rasmi Pertubuhan
Jamaah Islah Malaysia (JIM) melainkan yang dinyatakan sedemikian.

Sila ke "JIM E-Bazaar" untuk membeli belah, membayar yuran program dan 
menyumbang untuk dakwah, di http://www.jim.org.my/e-bazaar/

Untuk melanggan Islah-Net, hantar e-mail ke [email protected]
Untuk menghentikan langganan, hantar e-mail ke 
[email protected]! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/islah-net/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/islah-net/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke