On 2002.04.24 17:46:04 -0400 Jason Dillon wrote: > > Tyrex works in 3.0 (at least it did about 2 months ago when I patched > it > > up). I would not recommend Tyrex for work in distributed transactions, > > because it would be very slow. It should work fine as a local TM as > well > > but, probably, it is slower than JBossTX. To get it to work you would > have > > How much slower compaired to how much more robust? Can we fix some of > its > slowness? > > I don't have lots of evidence to back this up yet... but I think our fast > tx > manager is not very robust and reliable... but that is just a feeling I > have > right now.
It doesn't pretend to do logging, which is what you need for failure recovery and reliable 2pc. Do you have any evidence that anything else is ever causing problems in it? Much to my surprise, all the bugs I've thought were definitely in the tx manager turned out to be in my code;-) (OK, there were a couple of minor tweaks I made). Tyrex is way way way more than a tx manager-- it includes all sorts of things such as connection pooling. I don't think relying on it is a terribly good idea for the long term. I would rather see us add logging to our tm. Perhaps we can get Ole to give us a little advice on this one. If we use the jdk 1.4 nio maybe it even won't be ridiculously slow;-) david jencks > > I would rather have slower and more stable than super quick... but right > now I > would not trust using Tyrex, because hardly anyone uses it with JBoss. > > It's open source (are the licenses compatible... don't know, have not > cjecked > what the exact license is), if it is more feature rich why don't we > integrate > it at the source level then work on fixing its speed issues? > > > to tweak some build files, though, since I never had a chance to make > it a > > SAR, the tyrex-plugin.jar does not get built, though the classes are > > compiled > > Please don't turn it into a .sar... leave it as a .jar + .xml (see my > previous > rants about this). > > --jason > > > ------------------------------------------------- > This mail sent through IMP: http://horde.org/imp/ > > _______________________________________________ > Jboss-development mailing list > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development > > _______________________________________________ Jboss-development mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development
