Title: RE: Integration of Cocoon and Jetspeed; is Turbine a liability?

[Sorry for the HTML format, this is a bug (Q222508) in our Exchange
server machine that the sysadmins have been too lazy to fix...]


Hi Kevin, and thanks for your time.

> > I guess this is the crux of the issue to me. I can see my apps
> > will require user authentication, session management, etc., so
> > it looks like Turbine would be a good fit. But we have also
> > made the decision to provide all content with XML, and use XSL
> > for presentation; even more, we would really like to separate
> > the groups working on the logic, content (data) and presentation,
> > and Cocoon looks like a very good fit for this. How could I mix
> > both alternatives?
>
> Use Jetspeed portlets.  You get all this for free.  :)  The only
> drawback is that you are stuck with Turbine layout.  It is possible to
> do whatever you want with this but you have to write Java or
> stick with the current implementations and PSML.

Kevin, I know you must be awfully busy, but could you expand a little
more on this suggestion, and its drawbacks? FWIW, I don't mind at all
writing Java code; actually, I expect it to be necessary . Anyway,
if I'm reading you correctly, it should be possible to:

* Write a portal-like site with Jetspeed.
* Automatically connect to "news-like" sources of information (Slashdot,
  NY Times, whatever) using the Jetspeed facilities.
* Have one of these "sources of information" actually be a Cocoon-based
  app that links to whatever legacy system I want to integrate.

> I need to start the path down a CocoonPortletController.  It should be
> impossible but just something that everyone has been arguing about....

I didn't understand what you said here...


One more thing: do you agree with this assertion by Rapha�l Luta?

> Jetspeed is not an application or publication framework. I don't see
> *anybody* building a whole site with jetspeed. Jetspeeed is used to
> aggregate contents and publish this in one or several screens.

Thanks for all the useful input,


--
Gonzalo A. Diethelm
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
If this mail is in HTML format, blame Exchange Server: Q222508

Reply via email to