Florian, if we would push the latest version to the Sandbox, would you be able to recreate the problem there ?
2008/8/19 Andrew Jaquith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > I really don't know what to say about this. We have lots and lots of unit > tests for ACLs, and many web unit tests that test things from the browser. > > All of these tests work fine. > > Unless we can devise some tests that allow reproduction of the issue, every > time, it's going to be hard for me to help. > > Florian, I do not doubt that you are having > > > On Aug 19, 2008, at 8:14 AM, Florian Holeczek <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Interesting... in my case, the affected pages are viewable, but >> nothing more. Also, administrators do have full access to it like they >> should. >> >> I have some "allow view all" page ACLs in the pages. Could you check >> for page ACLs maybe in a backup from the time when you had the >> problem? Maybe the ACLs shift somehow in memory. >> >> This brought me to the idea of testing it without the page cache. >> This is spooky... >> Without cache, the error appears in another way. >> * Pages appear with their correct ACLs. They were editable, but: The >> changes aren't saved! >> * However, no error appears, JSPWiki is behaving as if the save action >> has been handled correctly. >> * Adding comments to these pages works, but the comment itself isn't >> written into the page, only the signature. >> >> Like Janne assumed, this could in fact be related to JSPWIKI-27. >> However, the problem described there isn't that dramatic, but the >> "full error" I'm describing here is pretty severe, I think. >> >> I'm experiencing the problem with the current head of trunk (alpha-21 >> at the moment). >> >> Andrew, what do you think about it? AFAIK you're the AAA expert in >> here. >> >> Regards >> Florian >> >> Ursprüngliche Nachricht vom 19.08.2008 um 10:18: >> >>> Florian, >>> >> >> I think we had similar problems in the past (unfortunately my long term >>> memory is bad). >>> The symptoms were that (mostly) the main page was not publicly accessible >>> anymore, only for administrators. >>> Looking at the source of the page, there were no ACL's on it. >>> The workaround for this was always Edit the page (add something to it) >>> and >>> save it. >>> This problem occurred on average 3 times a week. >>> >> >> The problem was solved after an upgrade, but I don't know anymore to >>> which >>> version (you can see the version history on my personal page on >>> jspwiki.org >>> ). >>> >> >> We currently run 2.7.0-svn-44, and we don't have the problem anymore. >>> >> >> Hope this helps, >>> Harry >>> >> >> -- met vriendelijke groet, Harry Metske Telnr. +31-548-512395 Mobile +31-6-51898081
